Butters & Co.Bakery

Ending the weekend with a NEW COOKIE ❗️❗️❗️

CINNAMON CHOCOLATE SMORES 🔥

This decadent cookie has a chocolate and cinnamon graham cracker base, a marshmallow filling and is topped with toasted cinnamon graham crackers, dark chocolate chips & sea salt 🤤

They are soft, gooey, sweet, and the perfect summer treat 🍪

#614

Cookie bracket winner!! 🍪🥛

Cookies & Cream will be 50% off for pickup this weekend. Message me your orders!

Full dozen - $17
1/2 dozen - $8.50
Single - $2

HAPPY FRIDAY 🍪

These soft carrot cake cookies are the perfect dessert for Easter 🥕🐰 Message me your orders for next weekend!

#614

💘 GIVEAWAY 💘

Enter to win a Valentine’s Sampler box 🍪

How to enter:
1. Like this post
2. Tag someone you love 💗
3. Both must be following

Winner will be selected 2/8 - pickup for cookies on 2/10 in Westerville

The box includes:
🍪 Lemon + Raspberry
🍪 Cinnamon + Salted Caramel
🍪 Strawberry + Oreo
🍪 Lavender + Lemon
🍪 Salted Brownie
🍪 Salted PB Brownie
🍪 Cherry Pop-tart

#614

Happy Sunday
💘

Very excited to announce the Valentine’s Day variety box 🔥 now available to pre-order for pickup on February 10th or 11th.

The box includes:
🍪 Lemon + Raspberry
🍪 Cinnamon + Salted Caramel
🍪 Strawberry + Oreo
🍪 Lavender + Lemon
🍪 Salted Brownie
🍪 Salted PB Brownie
🍪 Cherry Pop-tart

Large box (14 pieces) ~ $28
Small box (7 pieces) ~ $14

Message me to order!

#614

🔥 NEW 🔥

Try these 3 new cookies in the Oreo Sampler! Now available to preorder for pickup on 1/20 or 1/21

Which one do you want?!
🍪 M&M
🍪 Cookie Monster
🍪 Caramel + Toffee

Message me to order!

#614

Happy New Year ✨

We are starting off 2024 with a fan favorite sampler pack ~ OREO SAMPLER

We will be releasing 3 new flavors in this pack + 3 of 2023 best sellers. The sampler includes:
🍪 Cookies and Cream
🍪 Cookie Monster *new*
🍪 M&M *new*
🍪 Toffee + Caramel *new*
🍪 S’mores
🍪 Funfetti

Pre orders now available for pickup on January 20th or 21st.

If you donate a winter coat, hat and gloves, or sleeping bag you will receive $5 off your order!

Normal price
$35 - full dozen (2 of each flavor)
$20 - half dozen (1 of each flavor)

Price with a donation
$30- full dozen
$15 - half dozen

Pickup time and address will be discussed during ordering. Message or email me to place your orders or if you have any questions 🍪

Hello everyone 👋🏻

I don’t think I’ve ever done a formal introduction so here we are 😄

My name is Christine, owner of Butters & Co. Bakery 🧈

Get to know me👩‍🍳
~I work as an event planner for a corporate hotel so my baking is limited to evenings and weekends
~I moved to Columbus about 8 years ago after graduating from BGSU (talons up 🦅)
~My husband and I recently bought our first home in Westerville
~My favorite thing about Butters & Co. is coming up with fun and unique flavors
~My least favorite thing is doing the dishes
~My favorite cookies I’ve made are Mexican hot chocolate, lemon + rosemary, and grapefruit + fennel. I gravitate towards savory flavors so if you’re like me, you need to try these cookies 🔥
~My favorite cocktail is a vodka martini with blue cheese stuffed olives or a gin and tonic
~I love music and going to concerts with my husband
~I also enjoy working out, being outside (specifically being by Lake Erie) cooking, bravo reality tv, and spending time with family and friends.

It has been such an amazing, rewarding, and exciting experience running my own home bakery and I’m excited to see what 2024 holds ✌🏻

THANK YOU for being here! I truly appreciate all the support ♥️

I hope everyone has a wonderful, safe and healthy holiday 🌲

🚨 UPCOMING MARKET 🚨

We will be on Saturday 11/25 at 11am for a market

We will have some new holiday flavors + some of our fan favorites 🍪

Can’t wait to see you all there 😄

#614

We teamed up with Butters & Co.Bakery to pair their amazing cookies with our delicious brews! Don’t miss out on this sweet pairing on October 17th. Get your ticket now: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/fall-beer-cookie-pairing-tickets-722097843087?aff=ebdsoporgprofile

With all the hype around Barbie and our new pink logo we have to share this funfetti cookie cake 😍💕🥳

Blueberry Pop-Tart 🍪🫐

This may be our new favorite 🤤

Now available all spring by the dozen!

#614

HAPPY FRIDAY

🎉💕🦛🐘🎂🍪🎊

📷: Funfetti Cookie Cake

#614

Coming in hot with this December cookie 🔥

MEXICAN HOT CHOCOLATE

This is a fudgy and rich chocolate cookie with cinnamon & cayenne pepper + a few mini marshmallows giving it a sweet vanilla flavor.
This cookie is sweet with a spicy finish 🌶

This may be one of our favorites for December 😋

Happy Saturday 🏈

📷: Brutus Cookie Cake 🥜

#614

HAPPY FALL 🍂 🎃

We are super excited to announce our new fall flavors that will be available today-Thanksgiving!

~Cinnamon Sandwiches with a Pumpkin Buttercream
~Pumpkin Spice + Heath
~Mocha + Oreo
~Brown Butter + Butterscotch + Salt
~Orange + Allspice
~Oatmeal + Apple with a Maple + Bourbon Glaze

What flavor are you most excited to try?!

#614

Happy July 🥥

I hope everyone has a fun and safe holiday weekend 🎆

#614

German Chocolate 🍪

This rich cookie is full of cocoa powder, dark chocolate chips, pecans, coconut flakes & extract 🥥

This cookie will be available this Sunday from 3-7.

#614

Mark your calendars for the Father’s Day music market next Sunday from 3-7 🌞

We will be there with 3 other vendors + live music + beer + ray rays + Mikey’s pizza. What more could you want??
🍪 🍻 🎶

Menu for Butters & Co.
-Cookies & Cream
-Espresso Chocolate Crunch
-Salted Caramel + PB + M&M Bars
-Basil + Lime
-Oreo + S’mores ft. Land-Grant S’mudder s’mores brown ale
-German Chocolate Cake
(dark chocolate, coconut and pecans)
-Lemon + Rosemary

All cookies will be sold individually, we will also have some free samples 🍪

Can’t wait to see you all there 😃

#614

Peanut Butter + M&M + Pretzel

🔥

#614

Salted Caramel + Chocolate + Coconut Bars
🥥

These cookie bars have chocolate chips, unsweetened coconut flakes, and a-little coconut extract. In the middle they are filled with a rich caramel sauce and sea salt. Each bar is topped with a coconut dream cookie.

These will be available at the tomorrow from 9am-1pm!

🍪

Salted Caramel + Coffee Bars
☕️

These bars are loaded with chocolate chips, espresso powder and a rich caramel sauce. They are topped with chocolate covered espresso beans and sea salt.
Available tomorrow morning at the

#614

🥳🎉🦄

COOKIE + BEER PAIRING
🍪 🍻

We are super excited to announce that we will be at Taft’s Brewpourium on Wednesday May 18th for a cookie and beer pairing.

With your ticket, you will get 4 beer tastings and 4 cookies!
1. Basil + Lime Cookie 🌿 Paired with Key Lime Ale
2. Cookies & Cream Cookie 🍪 Paired with Maverick Chocolate Porter
3. Salted Caramel + Coffee Bars ☕️ Paired with Stay Classy Porter
4. Lemon + Rosemary Cookie 🍋 Paired with Blueberry Lemon Fruit Tart

Get your tickets below!!
https://www.eventbrite.com/e/beer-cookie-pairing-tickets-323234451947?aff=ebdsoporgprofile

Valentine's Day Recap 💘

Just because Valentine's Day is over doesn't mean the sweets have to be. 🍪
We are excited to announce a new flavor that will be added to our year round menu.

FUNFETTI
🦄🥳

This giant cookie is packed full of regular Oreos, golden Oreos and sprinkles. It is sweet and soft.

Available by the half or full dozen.
1/2 ~ $16
Full ~ $32

Message me your orders!

Happy Holidays!

Our holiday sampler is here! We are offering a build your own box this holiday season. Mix and match however you would like 🎄

Message me your orders or any questions.
Pickup will be 12/23.

🍪🎅

Land Grant Market Menu 🍪

Mark your calendars for 10/10 to try these delicious fall cookies!
🎃

Which one are you excited to try??