Classy Girl Cupcakes

Classy Girl Cupcakes

See pinned carryout menu for flavors of the month!:) **Carryout Menu of daily flavors changes monthly, see pinned menu for today’s flavors. xoxo

Call ahead or simply stop in to purchase from daily menu! :) **

Custom cake & cupcake orders can be placed with 3-5 days notice! Here are 3 ways you can pre-order:
(phone) 414/270-1877
(email) [email protected]
(online) ClassyGirlCupcakes.com

Thank you for all of your support!

15/06/2024

🩶Congratulations Lauren & David🩶 2.24.24 at The Fitzgerald MKE

15/06/2024

💗Congratulations Jennifer & Steve💗 2.24.24 at Pabst Mansion

14/06/2024

🧁CRAZY CUPCAKE AUCTION!!🧁This box has jumbo filled cookie dough, chocolate and vanilla flowers, mini chocolate mint, cherry vanilla cupcakewiches, and standard size snickerdoodle, red velvet, and salted caramel fudge! Bid by commenting below, no splitting please. Cupcakes can be stored in an air tight manner and eaten within a couple days or frozen for a later date. Starting bid is $40 and bids must increase by $1+ increments (feel free to bid higher, just nothing less than $1 at a time:) Bid often to increase your chances and turn on your notifications! Auction will end at 10am. HAVE FUN😁!! *winner must call 414/270-1877 to pre-pay, and pick up by 6pm!*

😊!PLEASE READ!😊Winner must confirm pick up by close today at 6pm at our Cathedral Square location. Confirmation of your win must be made within 20 minutes after the bidding closes, or we move onto the next highest bidder. Winner must call 414/270-1877 to pre-pay. Bidding is meant to be fun and quick, arguing and disagreement are not allowed. Do not bid if you are going to delete your bid, cannot confirm within 20 minutes, cannot call to pre-pay, or cannot pick up by close. Decisions made by CGC staff are final and non-negotiatable. We reserve the right to ban a user from future auctions if these terms are abused. Auction items may be imperfect, day old, or damaged, and all sales are final. We do not offer refunds, credits or exchanges. By bidding below, you agree to these terms. Thank you for reading the rules!

13/06/2024

Happy birthday, Coco!💕🌸

13/06/2024

💗Congratulations Tessa & Jacob💗 12.30.23 at Filament

13/06/2024

A tiny 🍸 bit older (& engaged!)💍🥰
https://www.classygirlcupcakes.com/product/vintage-heart-shaped-cake/

12/06/2024

❤️Congratulations Jackie & Nick❤️ 12.2.23 at St. James 1868 Event Venue

12/06/2024

Bright ombre, white chocolate drip & crystal sugar, makes a fun & funky birthday cake ✌️🩵💚💙
https://www.classygirlcupcakes.com/product/heart-drip-layer-cake/

11/06/2024

🧡Congratulations Sarah & Jonathan🧡 11.25.23 at Birch

11/06/2024

Delicate buttercream piped vines, buds & greenery, accented with classic roses- perfect for any baby or bridal shower 🌿🤍✨
https://www.classygirlcupcakes.com/product/greenery-wreath-layer-cake/

Photos from Forward Art Initiative's post 11/06/2024
11/06/2024

🤎Congratulations Kirsten & Sam🤎 11.11.23 at Saint Kate - The Arts Hotel

07/06/2024

🧡Congratulations Rian & Andrew🧡 11.4.23 at Historic Courthouse 1893

Photos from 3pyrsinapod's post 07/06/2024
07/06/2024

Happy from Lizzie! Lizzie recently celebrated her 101st birthday and she had an amazing party at her day program. Thank you to our friends at Classy Girl Cupcakes for making the day extra special with a cake for Lizzie and her friends.

Classy Girl Cupcakes

07/06/2024

Happy 11th birthday, Lilah💗🌸🌿🌼✨
https://www.classygirlcupcakes.com/product/floral-cascade-layer-cake/

06/06/2024

❤️Congratulations Caroline & Jesse❤️ 11.3.23 at South Second

05/06/2024

🧁CRAZY CUPCAKE AUCTION!!🧁This box has almond, vanilla, snickerdoodle, key lime, chocolate, lemon, maple, strawberry champagne, and jumbo filled vanilla birthday and flower cupcakes! Bid by commenting below, no splitting please. Cupcakes can be stored in an air tight manner and eaten within a couple days or frozen for a later date. Starting bid is $40 and bids must increase by $1+ increments (feel free to bid higher, just nothing less than $1 at a time:) Bid often to increase your chances and turn on your notifications! Auction will end at 2pm. HAVE FUN😁!! *winner must call 414/270-1877 to pre-pay, and pick up by 6pm!*

😊!PLEASE READ!😊Winner must confirm pick up by close today at 6pm at our Cathedral Square location. Confirmation of your win must be made within 20 minutes after the bidding closes, or we move onto the next highest bidder. Winner must call 414/270-1877 to pre-pay. Bidding is meant to be fun and quick, arguing and disagreement are not allowed. Do not bid if you are going to delete your bid, cannot confirm within 20 minutes, cannot call to pre-pay, or cannot pick up by close. Decisions made by CGC staff are final and non-negotiatable. We reserve the right to ban a user from future auctions if these terms are abused. Auction items may be imperfect, day old, or damaged, and all sales are final. We do not offer refunds, credits or exchanges. By bidding below, you agree to these terms. Thank you for reading the rules!

03/06/2024

🍌🍫JUNE MENU🧈💚 Special flavors this month include Bananas Foster, Butter Yellow, Chocolate Birthday, and Pistachio, plus Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter Oreo, and Salted Caramel Cashew cheesecake, and German Chocolate and Half Baked filled cupcakes!

Orders can be placed ahead at 📲414/270-1877 for no contact take out OR you can simply walk in to purchase from this menu during open hours. Please note we no longer have a seating area, all orders will be packed to go. We are closed on Sundays but still take Sunday deliveries & catering orders, just call or email at least 3 days ahead to place a Sunday delivery. We appreciate all of your support!🥰

30/05/2024

Hey 👋 did you know we have a carry out menu, fully stocked daily?! Yep! 25+ flavors for walk in, including our decadent jumbo filled cupcakes! 😋

Meet our Loaded Cookie Dough Jumbo🍪
A Ghirardelli chocolate pudding cupcake, stuffed with eggless chocolate chip cookie dough & fudge sauce, topped with creamy vanilla buttercream, cookie dough bits, fudge sauce & mini chocolate chips!🍦🍫

Available daily while supplies last 🧁
📱 414-270-1877 to call ahead or simply walk in!
☀️Open from 8am-6pm🌙

30/05/2024

Celebrate with buttercream confetti 🎉 🥳
www.classygirlcupcakes.com

24/05/2024

🖤Congratulations Lauryn & Brendan🖤 10.21.23 at Gather at Deer District

22/05/2024

💗Congratulations Shaely & Jason💗 11.4.23 at PIER 290

21/05/2024

Community Smiles Dental Event, 11.2.23 at Bluemound Golf and Country Club

19/05/2024

💗Congratulations Molly & Dylan💗 10.29.23 at Story Hill FireHouse

Photos from Classy Girl Cupcakes's post 18/05/2024

🎂CRAZY CAKE AUCTION!!🎂 Up for auction is a gorgeous 6” heart shaped red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting filling and vanilla buttercream, decorated with gold glitter and sprinkles! Cake serves 8-12 with nice size wedge slices, more if you cut them smaller. Cake is sold as is, cannot be modified & no splitting please. Cake can be stored in the fridge overnight and eaten at room temp within 3-5 days, or frozen for a later date. Starting bid is $40 ($85 value), and bids must increase by $1+ increments (feel free to bid higher, just nothing less than $1 at a time:) Bid often to increase your chances and turn on your notifications! Auction will end at 1:30pm. HAVE FUN😁!! *winner must call 414/270-1877 to pre-pay, and pick up by 4pm!*

😊!PLEASE READ!😊Winner must confirm pick up by close today at 4pm at our Cathedral Square location. Confirmation of your win must be made within 20 minutes after the bidding closes, or we move onto the next highest bidder. Winner must call 414/270-1877 to pre-pay. Bidding is meant to be fun and quick, arguing and disagreement are not allowed. Do not bid if you are going to delete your bid, cannot confirm within 20 minutes, cannot call to pre-pay, or cannot pick up by close. Decisions made by CGC staff are final and non-negotiatable. We reserve the right to ban a user from future auctions if these terms are abused. Auction items may be imperfect, day old, or damaged, and all sales are final. We do not offer refunds, credits or exchanges. By bidding below, you agree to these terms. Thank you for reading the rules!

17/05/2024

🐶Ella is one lucky pup her mom and dad saw our pupcake sandwich board on her walk!🧁

16/05/2024

💗Congratulations Kayla & Daryl💗 10.21.23 at Rustic Manor 1848

15/05/2024

🩵Congratulations Hannah & Benji🩵 10.22.23 at Discovery World

20/12/2023

✨🎄💚Holiday Hours❤️🎄✨
Saturday 12/23 10am-4pm
Sunday 12/24 *CLOSED*
Monday 12/25 *CLOSED*

Hurry up & get those orders in by today for the holiday weekend! *48 hours required for special orders* https://www.classygirlcupcakes.com/christmas/

About Us

Classy Girl Cupcakes was founded in 2009 when owner Erica Elia baked the cupcakes for her own wedding. They were such a hit that friends and family asked her to bake for their weddings and parties. An entrepreneur at heart, Erica realized how much she loved baking and needed a creative outlet to balance her career as a lawyer. She built a website and rented a kitchen, and in her first summer as a Milwaukee cupcake catering company, Erica catered 35 weddings!

Our mission is to create delicious cupcakes and cakes baked fresh 100% from scratch using the most natural ingredients we can find. We strive for just the right balance of quality, options, and affordable price to create unparalleled value for our wedding and catering clients. Our goal is to inspire positive client relationships for a lifetime of cupcake-worthy celebrations.

CUPCAKES: $3.00 each standard recipe; *available every day in store; special orders require minimum of 6 per flavor; $3.50 each gluten free/vegan (2-4 flavors each daily)

Almond - Banana Chocolate Chip - Banana Fudge - Banana Split - Bananas Foster - Black & White - Blondie - Butter Yellow - Butterfinger - Caramel Apple - Caramel Stout - *Carrot Cake - Chai - Cherry Vanilla - Chocolate Birthday - Chocolate Chocolate Chip - Chocolate Covered Coconut - Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie - Cinnamon Pecan French Toast - Coconut Cream - *Confetti - *Cookies & Cream - Cookies & Milk - *Ghirardelli Chocolate - Gingerbread - Grasshopper Mint - Hummingbird - Irish Coffee - Key Lime - *Lemon - Maple Bock - Mexican Hot Chocolate - Mimosa - Nutella Hazelnut - Orange Dream - Party Animal - *Peanut Butter Delight - Pistachio - Pumpkin Spice - Pupcakes - Raspberry Lemon - Raspberry Truffle - *Red Velvet - Root Beer Float - Salted Caramel Fudge - S'mores - Snickerdoodle - Strawberry Champagne - Strawberry Lemonade - Tiramisu - *Vanilla Bean - *Vanilla Salted Caramel - White Chocolate Blackberry - White Wedding

JUMBO FILLED CUPCAKES: $6.00 each; *available often in store; special orders require minimum of 6 per flavor

Banana Split - *Birthday Cake (Chocolate or Vanilla) - *Boston Cream Pie - Caramel Apple - *Chocolate Overload - Coconut Bombe - *Cookies & Cream - Creme Brulee - Dusty Road - French Silk - German Chocolate - *Gooey Pretzel Crunch - *Half Baked - Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae - Irish Car Bomb - Lemon Blueberry - *Loaded Cookie Dough - Mississippi Mud - *Peanut Butter Cup - Pumpkin Spice - Raspberry Truffle - Red Velvet - Root Beer Float - *Sea Salt Caramel - Strawberry Malt - *S'mores - Turtle - Tuxedo - White Chocolate Peppermint - White Chocolate Raspberry

Videos (show all)

🐶Ella is one lucky pup her mom and dad saw our pupcake sandwich board on her walk!🧁
Well, it’s not every day we get to have our cupcakes court-side at the Fiserv Forum during a Marquette University game 🏀...
Meet our Ultimate Oreo Layer Cake 🍪🍫🖤🤍🖤🤍                                       A decadent chocolate or yellow vanilla pu...
We strongly believe everyone deserves a special cake 🎂 or cupcake 🧁 for any celebration- no matter your diet, lifestyle ...
🐶A very special happy 1st birthday to Twiggy, our owner Erica’s miniature dachsund! Twiggy spent a fun filled day at Dog...
Our cakes are a labor of love 💕 From delicate scroll piping, to hand placed sugar pearls & piped buttercream roses-not t...
Behind the scenes 🎥 making our Tie Dye Layer Cake in primary colors 🎂🎨🌈✨ https://www.classygirlcupcakes.com/product/tie-...
Thanksgiving sugar cookie decorating kits in the making✨🦃🍁 A perfect activity for the whole family, order yours today! h...
Behind the scenes of a busy wedding weekend, frosting some Cookies & Milk🍪🥛 cupcakes for the Petersens 👰🤵‍♂️
Prepping a three tiered first communion cake, condensed into 30 seconds. If only this was our reality 😂 Just one of the ...

Telephone

Opening Hours

Monday 08:00 - 18:00
Tuesday 08:00 - 18:00
Wednesday 08:00 - 18:00
Thursday 08:00 - 18:00
Friday 10:00 - 16:00
Saturday 10:00 - 16:00