Rare Italian

Elevated Italian Steakhouse in the heart of Fort Collins. Open Daily, 4:00-9:15 PM. Happy Hour, Monday-Friday, 4:00-6:00 PM. Reservations avail on our website.

rareitalian.com Patio dining, weather permitting. Reservations available through our website or RESY.com. Place takeout orders via our website. Order delivery through our partner, Noco Nosh.

07/28/2024

Our wine case is stocked and ready for you! Join us every Sunday for 50% off all wines—because wine is meant to be enjoyed, not just admired.

🍷 Featured: Sassicaia, the very first “Super Tuscan.” We have only 6 bottles of this wine, so good they renamed part of Italy to honor it.

07/25/2024

White wine? Red wine? Something in between? With over 130+ carefully selected New and Old World wines, the choice is yours! Our knowledgeable staff is here to recommend the perfect pairing for your next meal. Join us and enjoy memorable dining experience. Cheers! 🍷✨

07/23/2024

Start the week off on the lighter side with the RARE Caesar. Chopped Romaine Hearts, House-made Focaccia Croutons, Shaved Parmigiano-Reggiano, Salsa Verda, (with or without) Anchovies.

07/18/2024

There’s nothing quite as satisfying as the first pour of the evening, setting the tone for relaxation and enjoyment. With over 130+ wines in-house, find the perfect pairing for your next Italian meal at RARE

07/14/2024

The perfect way to cap off the weekend - Sunday supper calls for unwinding and relaxing: join us for 50% off any bottle of wine from our menu, and raise a glass with friends and family.

07/11/2024

Meet our fan-favorite Ragu: house-made pasta, savory pork sausage, house aged beef ragu, Parmigiano Reggiano and fresh rosemary. It's Italian comfort in every bite! 🇮🇹❤️

07/08/2024

Some say Rare Italian has the best Happy Hour in town, and we can't help but agree! Come join us from Monday through Friday, 4 – 6pm and see for yourself.

07/03/2024

RARE Italian will be closed tomorrow, July 4th to be among family and friends — We wish everyone a wonderful Independence Day!

07/01/2024

Enjoy the sweet heat of our summer Calamari. 🔥 Chili-glazed calamari with local honey, julienned peppers, carrots, and pickled Fresno peppers. It is a happy hour MUST!

06/26/2024

Ever-changing and seasonally focused, our menu delights in the freshest ingredients. Dive into the delicious flavors of our Grilled Scottish Salmon, a limited-time favorite that captures the essence of the season. 😍

06/25/2024

Our chefs pour their hearts into every dish, ensuring each bite is a masterpiece of flavor and finesse. With pasta made fresh daily, made for you to enjoy. Come taste the difference! 🍝❤️

06/21/2024

We are here to elevate your next event to something truly special, whether it's a birthday party, corporate gathering, wedding celebration, or any other occasion.

Tap the link in our bio to contact us! 🍾

Photos from Rare Italian's post 06/16/2024

Out of all the names Chef Nate has ever been called, “Dad” has to be his favorite. Happy Father’s Day everyone!

06/14/2024

Have you tried the Agnolotti yet? Picture braised beef, handmade sausage, Parmigiano-Reggiano, in a rich beef brodo, topped with fresh pea tendrils. Yes please! 😋

06/12/2024

At RARE Italian, we honor the art of savoring beautifully crafted, delightfully accessible cuisine, just as it's cherished in Italy. 🍝🇮🇹

06/10/2024

As we embrace the vibrant Colorado summer, soak in the sun on the patio!

Secure your reservation with just a click — follow the link in our profile to make one today. ☀️

06/08/2024

A lavish dining experience, complemented by all the right touches — cin cin! 🥂

06/06/2024

Experience exquisite cuisine amidst warm smiles — our dedication to superb food and beverage is matched only by our devotion to exceptional hospitality. ❤️

Photos from Downtown Fort Collins's post 06/05/2024

I think it’s safe to say it’s summertime in Downtown Fort Collins! ☀️🍹

06/05/2024

Our Caprino appetizer features whipped goat Cheese, olive tapenade, marinated tomatoes, thyme, and grilled Focaccia. A perfect blend of flavors to begin your culinary journey with us. 😍🥖

05/31/2024

Thrilled to share this glowing review of our Polenta Appetizer! "Once again RARE has raised the bar".... Thanks for the love, Denise! 😍

Ready to experience it yourself?

05/29/2024

For our veggie enthusiasts, our new Capricciosa Pizzeta is calling your name! Crafted with San Marzano tomato sauce, handmade mozzarella, artichokes, green & black olives, and spinach.

Share your thoughts in the comments below! 🍕✨

Photos from Rare Italian's post 05/27/2024

Today, we pause to remember and honor the heroes who gave everything for our freedom. Wishing you all a meaningful Memorial Day!

05/25/2024

Sip, savor, and celebrate National Wine Day with us at Rare Italian. Raise a glass to the perfect pairing of exquisite Italian cuisine and fine wines from around the world. 🍷✨

05/23/2024

At RARE, creativity isn't limited to our dishes. Our menu of artisanal cocktails is equally delicious, and made with just as much care.

05/21/2024

Our new entree item is one you won’t want to ignore...Pork Porterhouse Pepato. Savor succulent pork with Potato Purée, Spinach, and a flavorful Cognac Cream Sauce. Only at Rare Italian. 🍽️✨

05/17/2024

No need for reasons to treat yourself... just a reservation! Visit the link in our bio today!

05/15/2024

Indulge in a fan favorite appetizer - Arancini! Handmade Mozzarella, stuffed Risotto, and Marinara Sauce come together for a burst of flavor and crunch. Perfect for enjoying the beautiful weather! ☀️🍽️

05/12/2024

Food meant to be savored, memories meant to be shared. Buona festa della mamma! 💐🇮🇹

Photos from Rare Italian's post 05/11/2024

Congratulations to all 2024 graduates, including Reagan and Gina , two of our amazing team members at RARE! Your hard work paid off, and now it's time to celebrate your success. Congratulazioni!

Want your restaurant to be the top-listed Restaurant in Fort Collins?
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.

Our Story

RARE Italian reflects Italian cuisine as it's prepared and enjoyed in Italy, offering authentic, approachable dishes with a strong sense of place. At RARE, you can either enjoy your favorite dish or extend your palate to new levels of revelation. RARE is your journey of discovery filled with joy, community, and - more than anything else - deliciousness.

Videos (show all)

Our drink of choice? The signature Barrel-aged Negroni— a refined twist on the Italian Classic, featuring Spring 44 Old ...
From dough to deliciousness ~ watch the captivating tale of pizza unfold. 🍕#RARE #RareItalian #Fresh #Pizza #Handmade #S...
And…. exhale. You’ve arrived to the weekend, and just in time for happy hour! Monday - Friday, 4:00-6:00 PM. Saluti!#Wee...
There’s always room for dessert…

Telephone

Address


101 S College Avenue
Fort Collins, CO
80524

Opening Hours

Monday 4pm - 10pm
Tuesday 4pm - 10pm
Wednesday 4pm - 10pm
Thursday 4pm - 10pm
Friday 4pm - 10pm
Saturday 4pm - 10pm
Sunday 4pm - 9pm

Other Italian Restaurants in Fort Collins (show all)
Cacciatore at Heller's Kitchen Cacciatore at Heller's Kitchen
1939 Jessup Drive, Suite 110
Fort Collins, 80525

Joe Zeppys Joe Zeppys
Fort Collins

Joe Zeppys is an Italian Kitchen & Deli in N. Colorado serving up east coast Italian style cuisine

Marchitelli's Cucina Italiana Marchitelli's Cucina Italiana
2400 E. Harmony Road Ste. 101A
Fort Collins, 80528

Marchitelli's Cucina Italiana an upscale casual Italian restaurant featuring rustic Italian cuisine and the best wine we can find. We offer classic Italian dishes from all over Ita...

Panhandler's Pizza Panhandler's Pizza
2721 S. College Avenue Unit 4B
Fort Collins, 80525

Northern Colorado's Best Pizza since 1975!

Canino's Italian Restaurant Canino's Italian Restaurant
613 S College Avenue
Fort Collins, 80524

Celebrating the perseverance of Clyde, and Canino's Italian Restaurant. 40 Years!

Olive Garden Olive Garden
3905 S College Avenue
Fort Collins, 80525

From never ending servings of our freshly baked breadsticks and iconic garden salad, to our homemade soups and sauces, there’s something for everyone to enjoy at Olive Garden.

Carrabba's Italian Grill Carrabba's Italian Grill
1212 Oakridge Drive
Fort Collins, 80525

JJ's Wood Fired Pizza JJ's Wood Fired Pizza
4015 South Taft Hill Road
Fort Collins, 80526

Nick's Italian Nick's Italian
1100 S College Avenue
Fort Collins, 80524

Nick's Italian offers a current approach to classic Italian-American cuisine with a straightforward, yet sophisticated, high-quality menu.

Oregano's Oregano's
4235 South College Avenue
Fort Collins, 80525

A neighborhood joint serving tasty Chicago pizzas and Italian dishes. You can always count on a full stomach, great service and a good dose of garlic breath.