Notjoeaverage Bakehouse & Deli

We have a devastating and heartbreaking acknowledgment to make. Our beloved Lizzy unexpectedly passed away last week, at the young age of 35. Lizzy worked tirelessly with us every moment that we had our business, which forged a strong and beautiful bond between all of us. Lizzy was a very skilled baker and decorator who had an absolutely infectious laugh. She was a loyal friend and we are in complete shock. She was married to the love of her life just 6 short months ago and lost her father shortly before her wedding. As you can imagine, her loved ones are experiencing profound grief at this time. Her mother-in-law, Sandy, was also a loved member of our crew and relentlessly supported us- she is a lifelong friend. Those two were NotJoeAverage warriors. I always believed they were brought into our life as a blessing; one of a crew of ladies that sacrificed right along with us and worked hard with their hearts toward us. An enormous blessing! Please keep her family in your thoughts and prayers. Please allow her family privacy while they grieve. God bless you Lizzy. We love you. You will forever be in our hearts. If anyone has a special memory or experience with her and would like to share, please leave a note in the comments- we would love to pass on peoples’ delight with Lizzy, to her family!
Sincerely,
Amanda & Joey

Obituary information for Elizabeth Reyes Randall View Elizabeth Reyes Randall's obituary, contribute to their memorial, see their funeral service details, and more.

We’ve still got some goodies left! Closing up at 2pm. 4250 South 91st Street, Greenfield WI

Joey and I have been married 15 years, today! Time sure does fly! Happy almost Easter everyone! Just one friendly reminder that tomorrow at 9pm is the deadline for Easter orders. Everyone have a relaxing and safe holiday! ❤️Joe & Amanda

Highlights from Easter last year…. We sure miss you folks! Please check our post about our 2024 Easter Home-Bake-Sale!

🦋🐣🪺HI FRIENDS!!! 🪺🐣🦋 Please SHARE!
If you find yourself reaching for your readers and a light for this menu, there is an easier-to-read menu for you folks, in the comments.

Please share!

Mom’s classic KILLER TACO DIP Recipe!
Recipe is at NotJoeAverage scale, and made by a momma who measures with her heart! So, do what you will with the measurements- but these are the ingredients that our momma Amanda uses! See notes on ingredients that *REQUIRE* the pictured brand to achieve Mom’s flavor match! Enjoy! ❤️ We miss you folks!
Base-
* 9 lbs. cream cheese (room temperature)
* 24 oz. sour cream
* 3 jars *505 flame roasted green chile*
* 2-4 cups half and half (gradually add throughout process until you have desired consistency)
* 8 packets *Hidden Valley Ranch DIP*
* 12 packets *LAWRYS taco seasoning*
Toppings-
shredded pepper jack, shredded sharp cheddar, chopped green leaf lettuce, diced roma tomato, sliced green onion, sliced black olive, pickled jalapeño

To our dearest supporters,
Thank you so much for this experience of a lifetime! The memory of our store and all of you will always be treasured. We met AMAZING people, tested the strength of our bonds with our loved ones, we learned our strengths and weakness, and we learned some serious life-lessons.
We want to thank the amazing crew we had- we seriously love you guys! The spirit of our crew was one in a million! We want to thank our family and our kids for their understanding and support through everything. We are so blessed to have each of you!
Lastly, I would like to say that NotJoeAverage will never die- we’ll keep you guys updated when we’re back on our feet. I finally have the courage I think to sit down and read everyones comments and messages of support. We really have been in mourning. But, we know now that this too we will survive. Your support has meant everything to us!
If there is any interest in renting or owning our building- please message us immediately and we will forward you to the appropriate contact.
God bless! We love yous’ guys’! -Amanda & Joe

Hello Everyone,
I am very sorry for our absence, lately. I have avoided most of social media, my emails, my texts’, and my voicemails. I’m sorry for this, as I know avoidance is not the answer but this just has been such a difficult time for us. But, it’s time to rip this off like a bandaid….. Joe and I have decided it is time to close our doors permanently. This has been a heartbreaking reality to face.
We’ve gotten ourselves to a point where there is nothing left to sacrifice, and we have not had our heads above water for a good while now. It feels like we’ve come to the breaking point. It breaks our hearts to know that the limited resources that we can personally afford is what is keeping our store from its true potential.
We laid our crew off several months ago, as most of you may have noticed. We both picked up second jobs to carry the store. As you can safely assume having a second job and a family amongst other things- has shoved us toward burn-out with running an under-staffed store for 50+ hours/wk. I personally dropped the ball on a couple of orders because of this.
I am having a very hard time accepting all of this. It’s honestly almost felt like grieving. We’ve gone back and forth with our decision. It’s been very hard to put words to paper, I’ve written eight drafts of this post over the last week.
We are so sorry to all of you guys. We are so blessed to have had the opportunity to serve this amazing community, and to have met so many wonderful people, and to have learned the lessons we have along the way. Thank you so much to each and every one of you!
We will be having a cash only going-out-of-business blowout sale sometime in early/mid October. This sale will include food, some interior & exterior decor items, and several of Joes finished wood projects. I will post with an update on that so you all can come out and let us see your faces one last time. We will uphold all confirmed orders.
Joe has gotten back into his painting- so, if any of you have any projects, I just happen to know a guy! 🙂 Also, I will be looking into selling scratch-made special diet treats on Etsy, in the near future.
Again, we are so sorry. We HATE to disappoint you guys. We can not express enough gratitude for your continued support over the last 16 months. You all have warmed our hearts- we love you!!!
❤️Amanda & Joe

We are closed this weekend. Very sorry for any inconvenience. All pre-orders will be fulfilled.

This guy knows how to score points! Haha! Always love when someone calls ahead to make sure we have their love’s favorites saved for them!

DON’T FORGET… We have new hours!
Friday: 7am-2pm, 3pm-8pm
Saturday: 8am-2pm, 3pm-8pm
Sunday: 8am-3pm
2601 S Sunnyslope Rd., New Berlin WI
(414)794-3426
[email protected]

*THIS WEEKENDS DINNER SPECIAL:
Tacos, Burritos, Nachos or Tostadas
Mexican Rice, Mexican Corn, Beans & Watermelon
(Pizza, Burgers, Brats, & Hoagies will still be available. Saturday is our Special-Diet Baked Goods Day!)

Our Joey is 37 years old ( he thinks he’s 38, but, alas, he is 37….) today!!! His momma did a great job with him because he is one in a million! We all love you so much Joe, thank you for all that you do and HAPPY BIRTHDAY!!!!

Sooooooo….. if anyone is on the market for a tent, don’t be like us, who got this one. Impossible to get through to the warranty company too.

Perfecto! 👌

She’s aaaaaalmost perfect! 😍 A few more touches and its gonna be a whole NotJoeAverage VIBE! 🥰

A lot of info in one little post. Please share! ❤️

Unfortunately, we have a private family matter that is going to prevent us from being open this weekend. WE WILL HONOR ALL CONFIRMED ORDERS. Please just knock when you arrive. We are so very sorry! We appreciate your support! Thank you.

Hello everyone! This weekend will be a bit different than our usual, in the deli department. Starting at 10am- you can get loads of freshly cut fruit, roasted corn on the cob, dry rub chicken wings, 1/3lb burgers, brats and sauerkraut, shredded beef, carved turkey with gravy, or made to order pizza pastry hand pies! Come take part in our non-traditional weekend, until 3pm!

Lots of beautiful breads and treats to go with your meats and sides! Open until 3 today!

Hot Breakfast Hand Pies, Iced Coffee, and DONUTS galore! ❤️😍💕

We’ve got all the fixings to go with our famous weekend rolls and thinly-sliced Boar’s Head Sweet Slice HOT HAM! Come get some! SATURDAY & SUNDAY 8am-2pm! 2601 South Sunny Slope Road, New Berlin WI. (262)794-3426

ATTENTION!!! We have special hours this week and next week, as we are a vendor at the 55th Annual City of New Berlin 4th of July Family Festival!!! I’ve attached our festival menu and a schedule for the festival. If you know you need something for your holiday celebrations, please give us a call or send us a message, and we can work out specific pick-up times if we are able to accommodate you. Store hours for this and next week are as follows:

Wednesday 6/28: 7am-2pm
Thursday 6/29: 7am-2pm
Friday 6/30 through Wednesday 7/5: CLOSED!!!- FIND US AT THE FAIR (7/1-7/4)❤️
Thursday 7/6: 7am-3pm
Friday 7/7: 7am-3pm
Saturday 7/8: 7am-2pm
Sunday 7/9: 7am-2pm

Don’t miss your chance to get these delicious cinnamon rolls!