Old Chatham Creamery

Old Chatham Creamery has been making award-winning artisan sheep milk cheese and yogurt for over 25 years.

We make goat’s milk cheeses, 3 milk cheeses, and goat's milk yogurt with ingredients that are all natural, and milk from family owned farms. Established in 1993, Old Chatham Creamery was a trailblazer when sheep dairies were exceedingly rare. We also make goat’s milk cheeses, 3 milk cheeses, and goat’s milk yogurt with ingredients that are all natural, and non-GMO. Our milk is 100% sourced from ou

07/22/2022

Our Cheesemakers, Todd Pontius and Ethan Ott, taking home the awards from the American Cheese Society Competition!

07/13/2022

Shopping for our cheese In Baltimore? You can find , , , and now our at MOM's Organic Market.

06/07/2022

June is Dairy Month in NY State! Follow along as we highlight and celebrate dairy farms, creameries, ice cream makers and more for the month of June. We have a great selection from these vendors available all month!

Sweet Melissa's Ice Cream
Mercer's Dairy
BlueMarble
Great Lakes Cheese Company
Jake's Gouda Cheese
Lively Run Dairy
Upstate Farms Dairy
Yancey's Fancy
Chaseholm Farm
Adirondack Creamery
Adirondack Cheese Company
Four Fat Fowl
Old Chatham Creamery

05/26/2022

Taste our and at Roots Market in Clarksville MD today from 4-6pm.

04/26/2022

If you are at the Baldor Bites 2022 show, come by and see us!

03/30/2022

Our at BreadFurst in NW DC.

03/28/2022

Thinking about Spring time and picnics with our Hudson Valley Camembert Square, Ewe's Blue, and Fresh goat log with Herbs!

Photos from International Gourmet Foods, Inc.'s post 03/09/2022

We have a new distributor partner! Looking forward to working with International Gourmet Foods!

Mobile uploads 03/02/2022

Chatham's Trifecta!! Thanks

Another cool new product! 😎 This is a marinated cheese from Old Chatham Creamery. Got a little garlic in with the oil. The cool thing is that it’s a three-milk cheese; cow, sheep, and goat. You will need to give it a try soon.

02/01/2022

Happy Year of the Tiger!

01/07/2022

Nothing like a good sheep rodeo to start the year off right!

The Best Cheese in America: These Are the Top 50 U.S. Cheesemakers 01/03/2022

Thank you Food & Wine for including us in the Top 50 U.S. Cheesemakers! We have a great group of people who work hard at our Creamery to make fabulous cheese!

The Best Cheese in America: These Are the Top 50 U.S. Cheesemakers American cheese has come a long way. These are the best cheesemakers in the country.

Fromage fictions: The 14 biggest cheese myths debunked 12/16/2021

Fromage fictions: The 14 biggest cheese myths debunked You don’t need red wine, specialist knives or cheeseboards to enjoy this dairy delight

Timeline photos 12/10/2021

thank you Elizabeth Tippens

Fooood

12/08/2021

Many thanks to www.baldorfood.com, one of our valued distributor partners, for this beautiful photo of Old Chatham Creamery products!

12/01/2021

Does your cheese consumption increase during the holidays?

Consuming More Cheese And Wine Could Prevent Dementia Later In Life, According To Study 11/18/2021

Yes!!

Consuming More Cheese And Wine Could Prevent Dementia Later In Life, According To Study Everyone knows the old adage that “an apple a day keeps the doctor away,” but it may be more accurate to say that “cheese and wine prevents cognitive decli

11/15/2021

in NYC used Nancy's Camembert via the Bedford Cheese Shop to make this fabulous Baked Brie and Cranberry Tart Doughnut! Wow!

11/13/2021

What a display of fabulous cheese at Formaggio Essex!

11/11/2021

Admiring our Sheep’s milk yogurt at Grace’s Marketplace in NYC!

11/11/2021

Sunset at the Creamery..

11/04/2021

We are in the middle of National Fig Week! Nov 1-7. Figs date back to the Stone Age and we now have hundreds of varieties from which to choose. Smyrna, aka Calimyrna, and Mission Figs are most commonly grown in the US. Fresh figs are usually around from May to November.
Below are fresh figs stuffed with Old Chatham's Ewe's Blue wrapped in bacon and crisped in the oven!

10/26/2021

Have you tried our Sheep's Milk Yogurt! Besides being super rich and tasty, sheep's milk is higher in protein, calcium, potassium, vitamins A, B6, B12, and E compared to cow's milk . And it has all the 10 essential amino acids too!

10/25/2021

Dreaming of an Burger for dinner tonight!

10/22/2021

The sheep of Old Chatham Creamery want you to have a nice weekend! May it be filled with great cheese!

10/21/2021

It’s National Apple Day! Celebrating with our Hudson Valley Camembert (sheep and cow’s milk) and Blue Moon (goat’s milk blue) with Honeycrisp and Lady Alice apples!

10/15/2021

Had the ‘Tique Cheesesteak today for lunch. OMG! Flank steak, Taleggio, Garlic Aioli. I chose the GF bread instead of Ciabatta.

Photos from Old Chatham Creamery's post 10/14/2021

If you’re in Wash DC and looking for our Hudson Valley Camembert, try Bowers Cheese Shop at Eastern Market.

Anne Saxelby’s Legacy as a Champion of American Cheese 10/12/2021

We mourn the passing of Anne Saxelby, a great advocate for Artisanal American Cheese. Our prayers go out to her family.

Anne Saxelby’s Legacy as a Champion of American Cheese The cheesemonger, who sold strictly American-made cheeses, died over the weekend. She was 40.

10/11/2021

One of our young Nubians dreaming of great cheese!

Want your business to be the top-listed Grocery Store in Groton?
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.

Videos (show all)

Have you tried our Sheep's Milk Yogurt! Besides being super rich and tasty, sheep's milk is higher in protein, calcium, ...

Category

Telephone

Address


210 Gerald Moses Drive
Groton, NY
13073

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 4pm
Tuesday 9am - 4pm
Wednesday 9am - 4pm
Thursday 9am - 4pm
Friday 9am - 4pm

Other Groton grocery stores (show all)
Baker's Acres Baker's Acres
1104 Auburn Road
Groton, 13073

Over 1,000 varieties of perennials, annuals, herbs, trees and shrubs. Family owned business celebrati

Davis rd Pumpkins, Groton NY Davis rd Pumpkins, Groton NY
188 Davis Road, Groton, NY
Groton, 13073

Open Sept-Nov for pumpkins!! Check out Davis road Flowers and Veggies, Groton NY for the flowers a

The Farm Stand The Farm Stand
716 Auburn Road, Groton, NY 13073
Groton, 13073

@ Dedrick's Farm in Lansing, NY

The Good Neighbor Grocery The Good Neighbor Grocery
209 Peru Road
Groton, 13073

A little grocery store filled with good coffee, good sandwiches, and good people. Open Tues & Weds 6:30am-2:00pm, Thurs & Fri 6:30am-6:00pm, and Sat & Sun 8:00am-3:00pm.

Bad Apple Farm Bad Apple Farm
952 Lick Street
Groton, 13073

We are a family run farm with 3 local farmstands and an affordable CSA opportunity! Fresh vegetables

Finger Lakes Fresh Food Hub Finger Lakes Fresh Food Hub
210 Gerald L Moses Drive
Groton, 13073

FLF Food Hub is an 18,000 sq/ft facility that will provide a source for distributors to pick up a gre

Davis Road Flowers and Veggies, Groton NY Davis Road Flowers and Veggies, Groton NY
188 Davis Road
Groton, 13073

A local farm-veggie stand in Groton New York, offering many fresh-local grown products and goods.