Silver in the City

Purveyors of jewelry, gifts and whatnot. We’re a locally-owned small business. Currently offering online ordering at silverinthecity.com

We are a small, locally-owned shop with a big heart and desire to make your day awesome! Voted Indy's Best Local Gift Shop for the past 9 years - we work hard to share fun, unique items with everyone - helping you find great gifts at all prices. Established in 2000 on a street called Mass Ave, in a town named Indy, by a gal named Kristin.

09/09/2024

🐈‍⬛
Pssst! Hello there, human! Yeah, you!
If you would be so kind as to gaze into my eyes and allow me to briefly interrupt your regularly scheduled program [disassociation—doomscrolling—gleefreshing—schadensurfing].

I’ve come to remind you that Fall is nigh. Along with the approaching cozy sweater weather and the soon to be falling leaves, we've got going on, Autumn treasures are popping up on our shelves every day.

How’s about we share a slow blink for a moment, and then you can saunter over to https://bit.ly/3X6kHxX to see a peek what cool things are dropping?

Photos from Silver in the City's post 09/08/2024

🎉 Are you on the lookout for some Flair for next week’s debate and the exciting and nail-biting campaign ahead? We're not suggesting, like, 37 pieces of Flair—just enough to let your personality shine!

Our VOTE 2024 collection has just about everything you need, and it’s all cute. Stickers for your trusty emotional support water bottle? You bet! Awesome pro-voting bling? You know it! Fierce pro-women accessories? Heck yeah! Pro-Choice? Absolutely! Pro equity and equality for everyone? Right on! Fighting racism and standing against book bans? You got it! Pro-planet and pro-activism vibes? Totally! Locally designed and made? Check-checkity-check! And guess what? There’s even more!

We’re swooning over the new hand-stamped message jewelry from Evan Knox. You can't go wrong with the simple yet super impactful VOTE necklace or the fab cuffs featuring inspiring quotes from Michelle Obama and Amanda Gorman.

Check out the entire VOTE 2024 collection at https://bit.ly/3AWEZkW! Let’s get our Flair on!

09/04/2024

Another Snoopy board, you say?
Our response: But of course!
With this level of creative wizardry from our crew, it’s practically a moral obligation to share every single one!

Hold on a minute—can someone please explain why there isn't a Snoopy emoji? Who amongst us couldn't completely communicate our lives with Snoopy typing; Charlie Brown whiffing a football; Lucy's the doctor is in stand; Linus and his security blanket; or Woodstock just being the King?

Are the sneaky Deep Staters—who are definitely hiding evidence of the Great Pumpkin—also keeping our adorable Peanuts pals from getting their own emoji makeover? It's a cartoon conspiracy!

Oh, also, we should probably go ahead and let you know that we have some super delicious candles rolling in for Fall that you absolutely must pop in and sniff. You know, for science.

Photos from Silver in the City's post 09/02/2024

🇺🇸 🌸 🌼 Are you with Her? Do you like pretty vintage-y floral things? Do you have a yard or window? This yard sign just might be the ticket!

Kamala Harris for President of the United States of America! This yard sign was designed by Indianapolis artist Paula Shoultz with growth in mind! The early 1900s boasted some lovely seed catalog covers and that aesthetic is reflected here. The promise of possibilities that those catalogues represented can’t be understood fully by us today but with Harris as our Democratic Nominee for the President of the Untied States of America, maybe we will.

A “Presidential Mix” of botanicals grace this history-inspired yard sign: page-lavender for defiance, oak for strength and courage, poppies for regeneration, peonies for anger, nasturtiums for patriotism and conquest. Harris will defy the odds through her strength and courage, cut through the anger and help regenerate patriotism through unity.

These floral yard signs are a great way to show your support in style. 25% of proceeds will go to the Kamala Harris campaign.

Grab your yard sign along with our other Kamala goods in stores or at bit.ly/4dXo2oU

⭐️ NOTES ⭐️
Sorry, but these are not available for shipping. You can place an order for in-store pick-up or local delivery.

These signs are designed and paid for by local artist Paula Shoultz and are not affiliated with or approved by the Harris campaign.

08/31/2024

Our friends at are always on point with their Indy recommendations!

The Circle City is bursting with fun this Labor Day weekend 🎉 Make the most of your three-day weekend with these events. Tell us your Indy LDW plans in the comments!

🔗 in Visit Indy's bio

📸 / / / / .indy /

Posted

08/31/2024

Do certain numbers feel special to you because they keep popping up? Kudos! They are special! They're Angel Numbers, and are basically a cosmic high-five from the Divine (whatever you call it—angels, ancestors, the universe) letting you know that you're cruising in the right direction. So, whenever you spot your Number, just know it's a sweet little nudge from your Angel that you're smashing it!

We love this concept so much and hope you'll share your Angel Number experiences with us in the comments.

Rock your very own 18k goldfilled Angel Number necklace to keep the good vibes flowing! Come by the store to talk Angel Numbers, tarot, astrology, and more or head to https://bit.ly/4g04BgZ

08/28/2024

🕯️🍁
Even though the temperatures have zoomed back up to "Welcome to Hell" levels, the official season of pumpkin spice cannot be contained! It's about to get extra spicy everywhere, with pumpkin spice showing up in everything from coffee and beer to cookies and cereal to coffee and candles and more coffee.

Just for fun, we have an annual one-sided rivalry going with Starbucks and their autumn-inspired drink lineup. Last year, we were the reigning champs with the classic lineup: PSL v. PS(L) – the L stands for Love. This year, they swooped in with an earlier release and snatched the crown! Can you believe the boldness? We’re playing it cool, though—very demure, very mindful about our timing because the next few months are a marathon, not a sprint!

While we wait for Fall’s brisk days to roll in, we’ll be filling our spaces with the delicious aroma of the Pumpkin Sage Candle from Finding Home Farms, which you can find at https://bit.ly/4dLuEHi

🚚
Reminder that local orders are eligible for Friday Delivery!
Order between now & 10am Friday for delivery Friday between 10am & 4pm.
Perfect for home or office deliveries & right on time for weekend shenanigans!
Delivery zone includes most of Indy, Carmel, Fishers, Zionsville, and Westfield.
Option shows at checkout after entering address.

Photos from Silver in the City's post 08/25/2024

Do you sense that vaguely familiar feeling in the air? Can it be... HOPE?

After the thrilling excitement from last week’s DNC, we’re ready to take action! There’s so much to accomplish before November 5th – like urging our elected representatives to hear the voices of Palestinians and the Uncommitted, and to stand firmly behind a weapons embargo – but for the first time in ages, optimism is in the air!

We’re also over the moon about our fabulous little KAMALA collection. These stunning mugs crafted by the talented local artist are perfection! The wood wick 'I Understand the Assignment' candle from Effing Candle Company is truly a masterpiece. Those wooden Kamala face earrings are 😍! And the stickers? They make the best accents for any emotional support water bottle.

Don't miss out—get your own KAMALA goodies at our stores and online at https://bit.ly/4dXo2oU!

08/23/2024

Anyone else's dread-o-meter dropped down to bearable levels for the first time in awhile? We know there's a boatload of work to do between now and November 5th, but after watching the DNC this week, we're actually feeling optimistic rather than nauseous. Our HOPEY CHANGY has been activated.

Of course, everything starts with a simple act of VOTING. Are you registered? Do you have a plan? LFG!

08/18/2024

☀️🍁
Oh, the drama between Summer Stans and Autumn Aficionados.
Can't we all just get along? We have an Idea 💡.

Every August, Fall Folks get excited to jump headlong into pumpkin spice, spooky season & all things cozy, as they impatiently await a telltale chill in the air.

Meanwhile, Summer Squad clings desperately to the last rays of carefree adventure that their favorite season represents.

What if we told you there's a middle ground? Why not enjoy the best of both worlds in the magical season of Pre-Fall? What, you ask, is Pre-Fall? Well, it's an in-between season where everyone gets to enjoy whatever they want and everyone else does the same.

You want to embrace Autumn and put up spooky decor while sipping a PSL on an 87 degree day? Knock yourself out, sister! Your friend wants to live every Summer moment until mid-September poolside with an umbrella drink in hand.? That's a-okay, too!

In Pre-Fall, it matters not if you're Team Autumn or Team Summer, the world and our sneak peek Fall collection is for everyone! Take a looksy at https://bit.ly/3X6kHxX

Photos from Silver in the City's post 08/14/2024

How is it that it's almost the end of the State Fair? The time has gone so quickly. We've laughed. We've cried (mostly after seeing the – definitely haunted – Ugly Lamp Best in Show winner). We've ridden rides of amusement. We've eaten pickles on pizza. We've Dairy Barned and people watched to our heart's content. And yet, it still doesn't feel like enough!

We're still loving our Fair Fun collection, featuring the brilliantly punny Crop Top Tee as well as other veggie and Indiana celebratory gewgaws. Stop by the store or peruse online at https://bit.ly/3LYYtYs

Remember, if you're in our delivery zone that includes most of Indy, Carmel, Fishers, Zionsville & Westfield, you can order anytime during the week all the way up to 10am on Friday morning, and we'll deliver to your office or home by 4pm. Right on time for your weekend! Choose Doorstep Delivery when you're checking out.

08/13/2024

You guys! Just when it seems like our in-house artistic geniuses have reached the apex of cuteness and talent, someone just shoots for the moon and nails it. The original Snoop-Dog with the message to come *snoop* around our shop is

Photos from Lovely Homes by Skye's post 08/13/2024

😍 Don't you love looking at Indy through Skye's eyes!?

08/10/2024

🎡
The Indiana State Fair is like a giant love letter to all things Indiana – think agriculture, history, community, education, entertainment, and, of course, the epic food and joy. The 2024 theme, ”The Art & Nature of Fun," pairs perfectly with our whimsical fair-inspired crop of veg-forward goodies.

Shop State Fair Fun at https://bit.ly/3LYYtYs

08/05/2024

🚚 BEEP! BEEP! FRIDAY DELIVERY!⁠

Got a jam-packed week ahead with work, the Olympics, the State Fair, the kids, or just life in general, but you…

🎁 ...need something for a special someone (or treating yourself) by the weekend? We got that wedding-host-birthday-just-because gift you need.

👗 …want a pair of earrings to match your Saturday night fit?

🥇... are binging Olympics and dreading their end because Snoop Dogg won't be on your TV every day, and now you’re wondering how to fill that hole? Suggestion: Stream his music; make something from his cookbooks; and light a prayer candle with his face on it.

Our awesome team is here to make your life easier. While we absolutely love seeing you in person, when you place an order online anytime during the week and choose doorstep delivery, we'll put it together and bring it straight to your home or office by Friday at 4pm (see delivery area below). Boom! You'll be all set for the weekend!⁠

Ready to get started? Head over to ⁠https://silverinthecity.com⁠
⚠️ Heads Up! ⚠️
Orders need to be placed by Friday at 10am for Friday delivery.
We deliver to most of Indy, Carmel, Fishers, Zionsville, and Westfield. The delivery option will appear at checkout once you enter your address.
Meanwhile, LOL, why aren't there any Olympic emojis?
🔵🟡⚫️🟢🔴 🏊🏽🤸🏾🏃🏽🚣🏻🏓 🤽🏾‍♀️🏹🏌🏽‍♀️🏋🏻‍♂️🤼‍♀️ 🥊🐴 🏄🏾‍♂️ 💪🏽

Photos from Silver in the City's post 08/04/2024

🍅🥔🥕🥒
The magic of the Indiana State Fair is upon us again, and there's so much to do! Where's your go-to spot to begin? Fried treats? Thrilling Rides? Impressive 4-H demonstrations? Petting adorable baby goats? Performances? Liar's contest? Tractor shuttle? Giant cheese sculpture? Hook’s? Dairy Barn? Duck race? Indiana Grown products? Mullet contest?

We've got just the thing to get you in the fair spirit – the perfectly punny Indiana State Fair Crop* Top that celebrates Indiana’s agricultural bounty.

Swing by the store or head to our website at https://bit.ly/4fydw9e to grab yours.

Bonus: If you place an order anytime between now and 9am on Friday, we'll make sure it's delivered to your office or home on Friday by 4pm.

⭐️
*note: This "crop" top is a standard unisex tee, not a cropped top. 🙂

07/31/2024

Is there anything Snoop Dogg can't do?

From being a criminal to becoming a hip hop icon, an entrepreneur and a philanthropist, a youth football coach, a hilarious cooking show co-host (with his bestie Martha Stewart!), a successful cookbook author, and now America's unofficial mascot at the Olympics, Snoop Dogg has conquered the worlds of music, fashion, language, sports, and culture like a boss.

It’s the perfect time to light up… a Snoop prayer candle and dig into his stellar first cookbook, "Crook to Cook," which isn't bronze, silver, or gold – it's Platinum, baby. Quick tip: Whip up the Rolls Royce Peanut Butter Choco Chip cookies, a top pick from our Head Honcho! 🍪🔥

Go for Gold at https://rb.gy/wkxg4s

07/30/2024

In a blink of an eye, the Youths will start flooding back to school this week, leaving many parents scrambling to remember the concept of weekdays.

Whether the students in your life are filled with dread or eagerly anticipating diving back into the world of learning; and whether they're headed to grade school, middle school, high school, or college, the bitter-sweet final days of break can be a real rollercoaster ride.

A fantastic way to make the transition smoother is to make sure their back-to-school supplies aren't boring. Alongside the usual #2 pencils and index cards, why not add a touch of playfulness with something that will brighten their days? Might we suggest a vibrant lunchbox, a cute water bottle, funky glitter pens, handy notebooks, and stickers to decorate their water bottles and notebooks?

Spark joy with our Back to School collection in-store and our website at
https://rb.gy/afha5r

Photos from Silver in the City's post 07/28/2024

💚
𝕒𝕣𝕖 𝕪𝕠𝕦 𝕚𝕟 𝕪𝕠𝕦𝕣 🅱🆁🅰🆃 𝕖𝕣𝕒?

Is there a word for a group of brats? A mischief? A chaos?
Whatever the word is, let’s team up! A coven of brats can't beat. That's just science.

Is it possible to summon a vibe into existence? Because it feels like Brat Summer has always been there, chilling in the shadows, waiting until we needed it most. We've always been all about that chaotic, fearless, and playful energy, and now that things are getting extra wild out there in the world, Brat is here to help us through.

And even when the funky combo of lime, chartreuse, and slime greens stops trending, we'll still be vibing out our own ways and not caring what anyone else has to say about it.

Swing by, say hey, peep our peridot bling and cheeky brat necklaces, and keep doing whatever your bratty little heart desires!

Photos from United State of Indiana's post 07/27/2024

❤️🏅

Photos from Silver in the City's post 07/26/2024

We were delighted to join the monthly Creative Mornings' breakfast lecture series, a free event tailored for creatives (also known as everyone), where we had the opportunity to listen to a Grade A+ Flag talk by Michael Green, Founder, CEO, & Chief Flag Nerd of Flags for Good.

We’re big fans of Flags for Good. We love their flags and resonate with their mission, which aligns with our own values. Despite watching Michael's engaging videos (and Ted Talk!) on social media for a couple of years, we weren’t expecting how informative, funny, and inspiring his talk about flags would be.

Count us in as fellow flag nerds. As we’re processing some of the insights we picked up this morning, we just want to share a couple of quotes that resonated with us.

“We use flags to create what we want to see in the world.”

“Flags are tools to create inclusion and identity in safe spaces.”
*
*
*
We highly recommend giving a follow, as well as , and for the perfect space to have our minds blown about flags. Michael gave a well deserved shoutout to when talking about symbols and storytelling, so we’re just going to keep that shoutout going.

We proudly carry Flags for Good flags, pins, and stickers, but recommend you head to flagsforgood.com so you can check out their fantastic story and how they benefit our community.

07/26/2024

Can you believe it? We've zipped through the twists and turns of Summer Break and are now cruising towards the end. It's a whirlwind mix of emotions for students of all ages. We surveyed at least 3 returning middle and high school students and here's what we learned:

See besties everyday?

Get back on a schedule with a refreshing morning alarm?

School lunches can't be that bad, right?

Dive into new knowledge?

Rock fresh school gear?

What we've deduced from this very scientific study is that the Kids are Alright. It's likely they'll save us all. And here's what we told them to remember: Work hard. Be kind. Amazing things will happen.

Swing by our shop or hit up our website for a peek at some rad back-to-school gear. From funky lunchboxes to sparkly pens, cute water bottles, stickers galore, and more!

Check it out here: https://rb.gy/afha5r

Photos from Silver in the City's post 07/24/2024

☀️
It's not the heat that'll get you…
it's your dad telling you it's the humidity.

When outside is oppressive and adventures feel like a Big Nope, why not invite the great outdoors inside for air-conditioned expeditions? Dive into DIY projects, seeds, crafts, puzzles, games, model kits, flower covered everything, books about rewilding and gardening, and more

Shop indoor fun at https://bit.ly/3zRPpSp

07/21/2024

With all the fruity and flashy jewelry hogging the spotlight this Summer, our classic gemstone beauties have honestly felt left out.

Since *nobody* puts Baby in a corner, here's a little shoutout reminder to show them the love and attention they deserve.

Stop by the store to let all the gemstones – like these pretties from – know they haven't been replaced by bright, shiny, and colorful bling; and that there's room in your heart for All jewels, big and small.

You can also say hello from afar, by heading to our website at https://bit.ly/4bRvKze

Photos from Mass Ave INDY's post 07/20/2024

This is happening now, friends! Come on down to the Ave!

07/19/2024

So you know that we're pretty passionate about shopping local all year round, but there's a certain magical charm that can only be found strolling through the farmers markets and art fairs of Summer. Engaging with and directly supporting the people who grow and harvest food and flowers; who create and share artwork and music; and who bake with the secret ingredient (hint: it's love) is what builds a thriving Community.

Make sure your getting the full market experience by bringing your own reusable and eco-friendly bags, insulated coffee mugs, water bottles, something for the kids to do, and other must-have market gear!

Shop now at https://bit.ly/3W9XeKH, or stop by the store soon to build community with us!

The Mass Ave Sidewalk Sale and Block Party are Saturday (aka tomorrow) so stop by while enjoying the Ave and all of our neighbors!

07/17/2024

Any of the pieces from this dreamy collection from Laura Stark Designs paired with a power suit, playful sundress, or even denim shorts and flip-flops, make for modern charm with romantic flair and wanderlust vibes.

Bonus: Indiana Fever colors!

Shop Laura Stark at https://bit.ly/466BIuK

Photos from Silver in the City's post 07/16/2024

Summer? More like Yummer!

If you're like us and feeling fruity, come by to check out our juicy and cool Summer Fruit collection, or take a gander at https://bit.ly/464ogYi

07/11/2024

Everyone is welcome! Fur babies, feathered friends, scaly sidekicks, and... even humans 🐶🐦🦎

Stick a little love and pawsitivity on ALL the surfaces with something happy, funny, snarky, proud, or social justice powered stickers! Check them out at https://bit.ly/3LgqQRw

[Image of sign at Mass Ave, but your furry BFFs are welcome in Carmel, too!]

07/10/2024

Our teammates aren't just creative, cool, brilliant, and stinkin' adorable, they also have great taste. Next time you're in the store, ask the friendly faces what their faves are. Or keep a lookout for Staff Favorite tags!

Want your business to be the top-listed Jewelery/watch Store in Indianapolis?
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.

It starts with a desire to make your day awesome.

We’ve always been fans of thoughtful gifts, funny cards, offbeat decor, and gimme-worthy jewelry. We love cruising locally-owned shops in unique neighborhoods of the places we visit and we want to be a part of creating that neighborhood in Downtown Indianapolis’ Mass Ave Arts District. Fast-forward 18 years (wait, has it really been that long?), 14 of which we’ve been chosen as Indy’s Favorite local gift shop (our blush runs deep) by readers of Indy’s independent newsweekly, and we are still here (and in Carmel, IN and online at silverinthecity.com) and always working hard to share fun, unique items with everyone - helping you #win at gifting (usually while also picking up a treat for yourself).

We are a small, locally-owned shop with a big heart and desire to make your day awesome!

Videos (show all)

Don't miss your chance to nab one of these beauties before they hit shelves this week!
Okay guys! Be sure not to miss our preview of Evan Knox's Spring collection, exclusively available on our website this w...
It's entirely possible - likely even - that when the stores are closed, the ornaments come out to party on the shelves (...
We had a blast today sharing our holiday hoopla with the @downtownindy followers! We hope you all experience a festive h...
Does the thought of creating multiple gifts exhaust you? Look no further than our thoughtfully curated selection of gift...
So, check it out, this morning we found out that our buddy Heather Givens way over on the other end of Mass Ave at @Crim...
BTS 📷️When new jewelry comes in, and you get to  ̶p̶l̶a̶y̶ ̶w̶i̶t̶h̶ ̶i̶t take glamour shots for the website.Find the ne...
Although we've got the first of our Holiday Season Collections in stores, it still feels a wee bit early to be putting i...
Turns out GOAT not only stands for greatest of all time, but it's also an actual animal. 🌈the more you know!Check out ou...
HAPPY FIRST DAY OF FALL!Although we're already deep into Pumpkin Spice Season and full on manifesting all the goodness o...

Category

Telephone

Address


434 Massachusetts Avenue
Indianapolis, IN
46204

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 8pm
Tuesday 10am - 8pm
Wednesday 10am - 8pm
Thursday 10am - 8pm
Friday 10am - 8pm
Saturday 10am - 8pm
Sunday 10am - 6pm

Other Jewelry/Watches in Indianapolis (show all)
Katie Carder Fine Jewelry Katie Carder Fine Jewelry
Indianapolis

KATIE CARDER Fine Jewelry Handcrafted ♦ Curated Vintage

Gie's Jewelry Gie's Jewelry
Indianapolis

welcome to Gie's Jewelry🌸📿 and Store🛍👖👚

LOOP Permanent Jewelry LOOP Permanent Jewelry
Indianapolis

Loop Permanent Jewelry creates custom fit, clasp free jewelry that is welded on for everyday wear

Moe Pearl Page Moe Pearl Page
Indianapolis

Bangkok Thailand gold Pre order 😍

Regalo perfecto Regalo perfecto
6020 E 82ND Street 345A
Indianapolis, 46250

Regalos brillantes atu alcance precios accesibles para cualquier presupuesto 📍castleton Square mall

Auburn Clay Auburn Clay
Indianapolis, 46256

Polymer clay earrings handmade in Indianapolis, Indiana.

Monae’s Boutique Monae’s Boutique
Indianapolis

Customize jewelry

THōM Jewelry Co. THōM Jewelry Co.
Indianapolis

THōM creates modern jewelry for the elegant visionary.

Darlene’s Jewelry Darlene’s Jewelry
Indianapolis

Affordable, fashionable, and addictive quality jewelry

Twinkling Trinkets By Tricia Twinkling Trinkets By Tricia
Indianapolis, 46219

JUST CLICK THE SHOP NOW BUTTON AND CREATE AN ACCOUNT WITH REFERRAL CODE TM1993 AS WELL AS MY LIVE SHOWS!! AFFORDABLE FASHIONABLE JEWELRY, SUNGLASSES, SOCKS, BACKPACKS, WATCHES AS ...

Karmic Kaeos Karmic Kaeos
Indianapolis

Fizzy Fun with Heather Fizzy Fun with Heather
Indianapolis

Welcome! I’m so glad you’ve found me! Let’s get fizzy! What will you reveal?! 💎💍