The Picky Eatery

We haven’t posted in awhile but the Picky Eatery is getting ready to bring you sweet treats all week long!!

So no more having to wait for some of our delicious sweets 🍭 🍫

Making our fan favorites this weekend!
*
*
-No bakes $8
-Cheesecakes any flavor 12 for $10
-Nobakes 12 for $10
- Samoa cookies 4 for $10
-s’more cupcakes 4 for $10

Put in your order today and enjoy your treats this weekend ❤️

Mini pie a la mode 

The second addition to the menu is Samoa cookies
*
*
Everyone loves Girl Scout cookies but they are never available when you want them so The Picky Eatery is bring them to you all season long and these puppies are big !
4 for $8

The Picky Eatery introduces
Mini baked fruit pies
These ones are cherry but they come in all flavors !!
Enjoy a little slice of heaven with some vanilla ice cream ❤️

Good afternoon everyone❤️
It’s the weekend which means the bakery is open!

I will be making all the fan favorites

* No-bakes 12 for $8
*Buckeyes 9 for $10
*Mini cheesecakes any flavor 3 for $10
*Tiny cheesecakes 12 for $10
*Double chocolate loaves 2 for $8
*S’mores cupcakes 4 for $12
* lemon poppy seed muffins 4 for $10

Coming soon are some new and exciting treats this weekend so keep your eye out for them ❤️

The Picky Eatery would like to includes its new item to the list
A Deconstructed S’mores cupcake!!
4 for $12 !!
It has a layer of gram cracker crust, chocolate cake, and a cream cheese graham cracker frosting !
Perfect for any s’mores lover 🍫

2 orders are ready for pickup now

Any other requests
will be made to order next weekend

Lemon poppy seed muffins 🍋
4 for $10 or 12 for $15
Also in mini size 9 for $8 !

Why go BIG when you can go TINY !!
Try our new bite sized Lemon Poppy seed muffins 9 for $8 🍋

Our mini cheese cakes are perfectly bite sized so you can enjoy them anywhere!

Nobakes on sale now through next weekend
2 dozen for $12!!
(Originally $8 a dozen) 

Good afternoon everyone:)

This week on the menu, we have everyone’s favorites!!

*Any flavor mini cheesecake - 12 for $10
* Peanut butter no bakes - 12 for $8 or sugar free option 12 for $10
* Peanut butter Buckeyes - 9 for $10
* Lemon Poppy Seed muffins - 4 for $10 or 12 for $15
* Banana muffins with or without nuts - 4 for $10
* Banana bread with or without nuts- $15 a loaf

Direct message me for your orders
All goods are made on weekends, and will be ready for Pickup/delivery during the week!(Delivery fees will apply) ❤️

I will be adding new items next week to the menu so tune in to see !! 🥧

This delicious banana bread was a great addition to The Picky Eatery
$15 a loaf

Mini Strawberry and Blueberry Cheesecake
are on the menu 12 for $10!

Good morning everyone!!

New items to the menu this weekend are the following.

* Tiny cheesecakes 12 for $10 (choice of toppings)
* Lemon poppy seed muffins 12 for $15 or sold separately for $3.50
* Carrot cake cupcakes with cream cheese icing 4 for $10

Also for sale

* Peanut butter no-bakes 12 for $8
* Buckeyes 9 for $10

All baked goods are Made to Order

Message directly to place order !

Thanks again ❤️

Welcome to The Picky Eatery !
I have a wide range of sweet treats I make
I take orders on Fridays and fulfill all orders on Saturday and Sunday
Pick up times can be scheduled!
Delivery is an option for an extra charge
Message or call for orders!
I make new fun and exciting treats each weekend so stay tuned for what’s coming this week !!