Return to Odd Shop

Handpicked Peculiar Vintage & Modern Goods. Shop in person at Boneset Records in Madison, WI.

08/24/2023

See you at X-Ray Arcade this Saturday for the next The Punk Rock Rummage Sale (Milwaukee)!

Chile's Atacama Desert has become a fast fashion dumping ground 06/09/2023

Quit fast fashion!

Chile's Atacama Desert has become a fast fashion dumping ground Some of the developed world's favorite brands lie in discarded heaps in Chile's Atacama desert. How they got there tells the story of modern fast fashion.

Photos from Return to Odd Shop's post 05/26/2023

Pop-Up Market at Boneset Records + Sig’s Treasure Chest parking lot this weekend in Madison. Come on out! I'll have lots of band tees, vintage, and some modern clothing as well. Can't wait to see everybody!

12/27/2022

Happy Holidays from your local Sultan of Secondhand (right) and friends/purveyors of all things cool Boneset Records (middle) and Fovea Works (left) 🎀

Photos from Boneset Records's post 12/27/2022

Shop the racks in person at Boneset Records during their winter hours listed below!

10/02/2022

Coming right up! 👀

09/29/2022

Real excited to be part of this. Thanks to Alive and Fine for always putting on such killer 👀 events! More details to come soon, but plan to hang at Bad Moon Saloon on Friday night (10/14) if you’re into slasher movies and rad vintage!

Boneset Records, Madison’s newest record shop, is proudly woman-owned 09/19/2022

Boneset Records, Madison’s newest record shop, is proudly woman-owned Tucked in a basement in Eken Park, Boneset opened on Aug. 21. Owner Maggie Denman hopes to combine what she loves about other local record shops.

08/30/2022

In case you somehow missed it, is now open in Madison on Saturdays and Sundays. 👁 They’re a rad new shop with tons of used vinyl, tapes, vhs tapes, and more to come including newer releases on vinyl. They also feature a rack of Return To Odd vintage clothing curated by yours truly! ✨ I’ll be visiting Madison to restock & refresh the rack monthly, so come often 😏 It’s SO nice to have a permanent space that you can shop from back in Madison now that home base is in Milwaukee!

08/21/2022

Today is opening day 👽 it’s finally here. After countless hours and help from family, friends and partner Boneset Records opens its door at 11am.

You can park in the lot but the entrance is on the east Johnson side of the building. Look for the sandwich board 🖤

08/02/2022

Exciting news for my Madison followers! My good pal is opening up on August 21st and will be featuring a rack of my vintage clothing! Very excited to see their music taste curated into a whole dang store and super excited that they’ve invited me along for the ride. ✨

Read the article by for more info

Photos from Return to Odd Shop's post 07/22/2022

New upcycled Halloween earrings available on returntooddshop.com because we should all live like everyday is Halloween 👻

07/21/2022

Some recent additions to the website. I added close to 60 items last week so make sure to check it out if you haven’t already! Product tags in the post ✌🏻

07/20/2022

I know y’all are into shopping sustainably, supporting small businesses, and rad vintage fashion, right?! Giveaway closes on Sunday, July 24th. See the rules & enter via the post pinned to my profile on Instagram to win a $100 off coupon for returntooddshop.com! Love you all! 🖤🖤🖤🖤

07/13/2022

One more favorite from tonight’s drop before I retire for tonight. 😍

Photos from Return to Odd Shop's post 07/12/2022

A few more sneak peeks of some items I shot this week! Coming soon.

07/11/2022

Shot lots of cute stuff this weekend and will be working on measurements this week to drop on the website! Story sale/highlight prices from last week will be expiring at the end of today so check out those sale prices before they disappear! 🖤

Photos from Return to Odd Shop's post 07/07/2022

A few of you asked me about the gorgeous dress I had on my mannequin during the past couple of story sales so I thought I’d snag a couple of quick pictures for y’all. This is a rare Krist Gudnason Patchwork dress from the 60s. It’s made out of bark cloth and cotton and the colors are OUT OF THIS WORLD bright! It’s in great condition but is missing it’s belt.

Laying flat the measurements are as follows:

Pit to Pit -
Waist -
Hips -
Total Length -

Please DM if interested 🖤

Photos from Return to Odd Shop's post 07/07/2022

Some goofy screenshots to let you know that tonight’s story sale is LIVE! Woohoo! Check it out, and let me know if you like tonight’s theme 🦋

07/06/2022

Sneak peak at tonight’s story sale 👀 all items will be $10, $15, or $20 ✨ What’s catching your eye?!

06/27/2022

I realized it’s been a minute since I introduced myself and I’ve got quite a few new followers so hello! Allow me to introduce myself!

My name is Hillary, I’m a 90s baby and Return To Odd is my ode to all things nostalgic with an odd twist, most of the time. I’m big on acid wash, bold prints, perfectly worn t-shirts, owls, and so much more. Oh and Halloween, big time!

I’m what the kids are calling an elder emo with an interest in all things alternative, punk, horror, spooky, tattoos and lots of other fun stuff. 😎

Return To Odd is currently based out of Milwaukee, Wisconsin and all photos are shot out of my little apartment that I share with my two cats, Hitch & Pascal. I have a day job and fibromyalgia, so the energy I have for this project is limited but mighty. I have a major passion for thrifting and saving clothing and other items from landfills so I have a LOT of inventory. I’ve probably saved close to 4,000 items so far from going into a landfill by helping them find their new home instead.

I’m glad you came across my page and I hope you’ll share Return To Odd with all your weirdest friends. Very proud of the following I’ve gathered here and happy to provide for this community.

Thanks for reading and supporting!

05/22/2022

Pascal is here to let you know that everything in the shop is 40% off for the next 24 hours! Happy !

Want your business to be the top-listed Clothing Store in Milwaukee?
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.

Videos (show all)

Pascal is here to let you know that everything in the shop is 40% off for the next 24 hours! Happy #surprisesalesunday!#...
It’s just about that time of year again! I’ll be rolling my vintage and modern peculiar picks all over Milwaukee this Su...
Today’s the day! Stop out to Garver Feed Mill all weekend long between 9-5 for Midwest Vintage Flea ✨
A few new finds available on Instagram now! I found this (among many other things) on what was supposed to be a quick tr...
Sunday sneak peeks 👀

Category

Address


Milwaukee, WI
53212

Other Vintage Stores in Milwaukee (show all)
Minx Parlor Minx Parlor
Milwaukee, 53207

Virtual Vintage Shop born at UW Madison, raised by Chicago and thriving in the MKE area

Annie's Vintage Clothing and Rarities Annie's Vintage Clothing and Rarities
1512 W Pierce St And 1134 S. 1st Street
Milwaukee, 53204

Etsy.com/shop/antique or 1512 West Pierce Street MKE (inside Antiques on Pierce-2nd floor) MKE WI or call 414-727-5586 for all your vintage clothing needs!

Luv Unlimited Luv Unlimited
2649 S Kinnickinnic Avenue
Milwaukee, 53207

Luv Unlimited was a new & vintage clothing shop. There was a fire in June of 2020 and our brick and mortar store is closed. Stay tuned for future plans.

Tip Top Atomic Shop Tip Top Atomic Shop
2343 S Kinnickinnic Avenue
Milwaukee, 53207

Voted "Best Antique Store" in Milwaukee by the Shepherd Express readers poll

Vintage Fresh Fitz Vintage Fresh Fitz
Milwaukee

Everyday vintage wear! 80s, 90s, early 00s! Follow the IG page for up to date new items and deals! h

ThriftSconsin ThriftSconsin
Milwaukee

Established 2021 We have vintage, modern, and retro clothing, as well as toys and collectibles!

Mid Century MKE Mid Century MKE
1134 S 1st Street Lower Level
Milwaukee, 53204

FindingFlora FindingFlora
Milwaukee

Hux, Lulu, Goldie, & Steven (my little family). Reading, coffee, knitting, the rain, music, traveling, & being at home. I got the antiquing bug years ago and it stuck. I love inc...

Clocktower Antiques Clocktower Antiques
1134 South 1st Street
Milwaukee, 53204

Welcome to Clocktower Antiques, Milwaukee’s newest antique destination. Located in historic Walker’s Point under the shadow of one of the city’s most iconic landmarks. We will be l...

Total Bettie Total Bettie
Milwaukee

Vintage-inspired shop based in Milwaukee, WI. We have a passion for all things retro/pinup/rockabilly

ADINA vintage clothing co. ADINA vintage clothing co.
Milwaukee, 53207

Earth forward fashion for the decidedly FEMME. ADINA Vintage Clothing Co. is all about the showstopper...the statement piece...the little something special. Close

Ash & Birch Co. Ash & Birch Co.
Milwaukee