Monty's Restaurant and Pizzeria

Monty's Restaurant and Pizzeria

Nearby restaurants

Dunkin'
Dunkin'
S Tamiami Trail

Authentic Italian Restaurant + Pizzeria Serving #PuntaGorda since 1983. Punta Gorda's 1st Authentic Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria. Established in 1983.

06/11/2024

You had me at "chocolate."

📸 flourless chocolate tort

06/11/2024

EDIT: WE HAVE PIZZA!

One of our pizza ovens is not working; so unfortunately, we will not be able to make pizzas until 12-12:30 today. We've turned on another oven but it takes time to heat up. We apologize for any inconvenience.

06/08/2024

Anyone missing their glasses?

06/07/2024

If you were sitting here, what would you be ordering?

Photos from Monty's Restaurant and Pizzeria's post 06/06/2024

If only dinner looked like this every night. It does at Monty's!

06/05/2024

If it's been a long hot day, don't make it worse by having to cook dinner and take care of dishes, too! We'll make sure you're well taken care of and can relax tonight!

06/02/2024

It's hard to skip dessert when it looks this good, so get it to go!

06/01/2024

Refreshing cocktails‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬‬ always tastes good on a hot day, but we've gotta say, it's even better when you're at Monty's!

05/31/2024

When you're not sure what you're craving, the answer is probably our pizza. 🍕

Dine In or call 941-637-0008 for Carryout.

📸: Barb Cunningham-Demaison

05/30/2024

Looking for the best Happy Hour in Punta Gorda? Come enjoy a cocktail, glass of wine or cold beer from one of our friendly bartenders, they’re always ready for a good time! Happy Hour daily from 4-7pm.

Photos from Monty's Restaurant and Pizzeria's post 05/29/2024

Don't feel like cooking today? Leave the cooking to us!

📸 Dizzy Nos

05/27/2024

This Memorial Day, let us pause to honor and remember the courageous souls who gave their lives in service to our country. Their sacrifices will never be forgotten, and their legacy of bravery and dedication will continue to inspire us all.

05/24/2024

Feeling like this should put a “pepp” in your step.

Photos from Monty's Restaurant and Pizzeria's post 05/22/2024

It’s finally lunch time. Fuel up with a variety of delicious menu items to choose from.

05/21/2024

Sometimes happiness is as simple as a couple of slices of pizza for lunch! 🍕🍕

Everyday ~ Cheese + add your favorite toppings
Tues + Thurs ~ White ~ fresh garlic, olive oil, mozzarella and blended ricotta
Wed + Fri ~ Sicilian

05/19/2024

All this cheesy goodness makes our mouth water! 🧀😋

Photos from Monty's Restaurant and Pizzeria's post 05/16/2024

Our dishes are warm and authentic -- just like our place.

05/15/2024

No one says you have to share but sharing is caring.

05/14/2024

An appetizer that will have you saying "Caprese-yay!"

05/12/2024

To the world, you are a mother, but to our family, you are the world.
Happy Mother's Day, to the center of your world.

Photos from Monty's Restaurant and Pizzeria's post 05/10/2024

Who's ready for lunch? We are!

Photos from Monty's Restaurant and Pizzeria's post 05/09/2024

"We had chicken marsala & chicken francese. Tracy was our fun server. The marsala was the best we've had so far and the francese was delicious. Each entree came with bread and soup or salad for only $20. We had caprese bites as an appetizer (sorry no picture) and total bill was $62.86 before tip. Yum. 😋"

THANK YOU, Karen Halmayr, for the great review and photos!

05/07/2024

Not to be cheesy, but this Fettuccini Alfredo is sure to please-y.

05/04/2024

Are you thinking to yourself, I could really use a cocktail? We can help with that. Cheers!

Photos from Monty's Restaurant and Pizzeria's post 05/03/2024

It’s hard to say no to our garlic knots!

Photos from Monty's Restaurant and Pizzeria's post 04/30/2024

🛑 STOP, don't turn the oven on today, let the Monty's do your cooking for you. Dine in, or take out, we will make your life easy today.

Photos from Monty's Restaurant and Pizzeria's post 04/28/2024

Thanks for the love, Mike ❤

* * * M O N T Y ‘ S * * *
2515 Tamiami Trail Punta Gorda

Going to start this post off with saying what great service was given to the family and I.

After 5 years of passing by this location we finally gave it a try last night and all we could say is what a mistake for not trying them sooner.

A must try for everyone here if pizza and Italian is your thing. Pricing was also great for its portions.

(The items not pictured were said to me amazing at home)
Items ordered:
Pasta Fagioli
Fried Calamari
Spaghetti Alfredo with shrimp 🍤
1 large cheese pizza
Chicken Marsala (not pictured)
Fettuccine Alfredo with grilled chicken (not pictured)

04/28/2024

Who doesn’t love spaghetti and meatballs 🍝 especially ours. Tonight would be a great time to come in and try ours.

Want your restaurant to be the top-listed Restaurant in Punta Gorda?
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.

Punta Gorda’s Original Italian Restaurant

Monty’s opened October 1983. It was the first authentic Italian Restaurant in Punta Gorda, Florida. For years Monty’s owner Diane Caputo thrived on treating her guests like family and creating a dining experience with great food that made you feel like you were home. August 13, 2004, changed that forever. Hurricane Charley destroyed the building in its path taking all that history with it.

Monty’s opened back up just a few short months after Charley in the Publix shopping center across the street, but not by Diane herself. She was selling the business due to her own health issues and to take care of her dying father. “It just wasn’t the same.” customers said, leading the business downhill. Diane just couldn’t let 20 years of hard work go down. In mid-2007 she took back over renaming the business Old Monty’s bringing back the old recipes and the old menu, so it was just like the old place. Through the recession, she rebuilt her reputation and decided to rebuild at the original location.

In 2009, Diane was awarded the 15th Annual Southwest Florida Blue Chip Community Business Award. This award recognizes successful small business owners who have triumphed over adversity and shared their stories as models for other entrepreneurs.

October 2019 marks 36 years that Monty’s has been in business supporting the local community with quality service and authentic food.

Videos (show all)

Category

Telephone

Address


2515 Tamiami Trl
Punta Gorda, FL
33950

Opening Hours

Tuesday 11am - 9pm
Wednesday 11am - 9pm
Thursday 11am - 9pm
Friday 11am - 9pm
Saturday 11am - 10pm
Sunday 12pm - 9pm

Other Pizza Places in Punta Gorda (show all)
PIZZA GORDA PIZZA GORDA
315 Taylor Street
Punta Gorda, 33950

PIZZA & CUCINA WOOD FIRE BURNING OVEN

Pi Local Pi Local
42091 Cypress Parkway Unit B1
Punta Gorda, 33982

Brick oven pizza, calzones, paninis, wraps, fresh salads, soup & wings. Located in Babcock Ranch, FL!

Wildwood Pizza Wildwood Pizza
117 W. Marion Avenue Suite #112
Punta Gorda, 33950

Wildwood Pizza is a speakeasy pizzeria in a back alley downtown Punta Gorda

Vitangelo Recchia Vitangelo Recchia
1938 Kings Highway
Punta Gorda, 33983

�Restauranteur, Pizzaiolo, Chef, Italian �

Manatees Pizza Manatees Pizza
408 Tamiami Trl
Punta Gorda, 33950

Serving lunch and dinner in Punta Gorda for over two decades, Manatees Pizza welcomes you.

Hungry Howies of Punta Gorda Hungry Howies of Punta Gorda
226 Tamiami Trl
Punta Gorda, 33950

Great food, great prices, great people!!!

Hungry Howie's Hungry Howie's
226 Tamiami Trail
Punta Gorda, 33950

K's Family Pizzeria & Restaurant K's Family Pizzeria & Restaurant
2000 Rio De Janeiro #7
Punta Gorda, 33983

K's Family Pizzeria & Restaurant founded 31 years ago, serves tantalizing Greek & Italian meals, appetizers, desserts, beer and wine. Delicious foods served in a friendly family a...

Papa John's Pizza Papa John's Pizza
2310 Tamiami Trail, Suite 3101
Punta Gorda, 33950

Vic's Primo Pizzas LLC Vic's Primo Pizzas LLC
16520 Burnt Store Road
Punta Gorda, 33955

Our restaurant combines homemade dough, a 112 year old sauce recipe, and the freshest ingredients to