Little Italy Pizza

Best Pizza since 1972!

03/12/2024

David Portnoy, founder of Barstool Sports and leading Pizza critic, made a surprise visit to Little Italy the other day. He had someone call in and order a pizza and about 15 minutes later he walks in to grab his pizza. We were definitely surprised to see him, and are very happy with our score and his kind comments.

What do you think of his review?

12/24/2023

Hello Everyone, below is our Holiday Hours. We hope everyone has a safe and wonderful Christmas. We also wish you a Happy New Year! 🍕🎆

Photos from Little Italy Pizza's post 11/29/2022

50 year anniversary was a success! Thank you to the amazing employees of little Italy.

Special thanks to Bruno’s Bakery for putting together the delicious pizza cake! It was so good there was none left at the end of the night.

Most importantly thank you to all of the customers, family and friends that came by to celebrate and show support!

Would love to see your pictures, send them to us or post them below.

11/28/2022

Hope everyone enjoyed the pizza cake from Bruno’s Bruno's Bakery Cafe!

11/28/2022

♥️

11/28/2022

Congratulations to this lucky lady who won a new Volkswagen Taos!

Thank you for everyone who came out to celebrate 50 amazing years 🥂🎉 🥳

11/27/2022

Come get it!

11/27/2022

⚠️Surprise Alert⚠️
Update: ALL TICKETS FOUND
Congratulations to the ones who found them.

We will see everyone tomorrow for the anniversary 11-8pm

Tonight! We have hidden a golden ticket somewhere in the Plaza! If you find the ticket please contact us through facebook!

-Please make this fair for everyone

-No Purchase Necessary!

-Happy Searching, Little Italy Pizza!

Photos from Little Italy Pizza's post 11/19/2022

Here is a sneak peak of the car we are giving away. One lucky customer will win this beauty next Sunday!

When? November 27th

How can you win?
-We have been giving away random golden tickets. During the anniversary everyone will also have the opportunity to win golden tickets as well.

Must be 18 years old with a valid Florida Drivers License.

What do you guys think?

11/19/2022

Hello Everyone, due to weather predicted for this Sunday we will be,
❌ cancelling ❌ the event and moving it to Sunday November 27th.

We waited 50 years for this day what’s another week to have perfect weather? 🫶🏻

Thank you for your understanding. We hope to see you next Sunday!

This year is the 50th year anniversary for Toby’s Little italy Pizza! We hope that all of our wonderful customers can come by.

We will be doing it big!!!!
One lucky customer will win a brand new car!
We have games such as pizza eating contest, pizza box making, and many more.

There will be raffles, some epic prizes and free shirts for the first 4,000 people.

For your chance to win the car, leading up to the anniversary we will continue to give out golden tickets. You will also have the opportunity to win during the anniversary where we will be giving out 10 tickets with no purchase necessary.

Please share with your families and friends. We hope to see you this year!

11/16/2022

We are now offering Uber Eats.

Toby's Little Italy turns 50, and celebrates with $.50 slices 11/16/2022

This Sunday! ❤️ 🍕

Toby's Little Italy turns 50, and celebrates with $.50 slices Toby's Little Italy will celebrate its 50th anniversary in St. Pete on November 20, and guests can enjoy slices for just 50 cents.

Photos from Little Italy Pizza's post 11/07/2022

Check out some recent pictures inside of the restaurant. 🫶🏻

09/04/2022

Starting today, we will be giving out Golden tickets. The golden tickets will be handed out on random days, times, and orders for your chance to win a brand new car! There will be a total of 90 golden tickets given out at the restaurant leading up to anniversary on Nov 20th. During the anniversary there will be 10 golden tickets that will be given out with raffles throughout the anniversary. Further information to come! Save our page so you can get more information and updates.

Keep a lookout on your orders, if you receive a golden ticket send us a message on messenger with your full name and number.

Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza 01/12/2022

Just going through some family pictures and came across this gem. Little Italy Sept 1972

Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza Toby’s Original Little Italy Pizza dine-in or take-out services offer one of the best New York-style pizza and subs since 1972.

12/24/2021

Hello everyone,

Please take a look at our Hours for the holidays.

Today we are open until 8:00 pm for Christmas Eve! 🎄 Tomorrow we will be closed for Christmas.

We hope that everyone has a safe and happy holiday!

-Little Italy Family

11/24/2021

We hope everyone has a great Thanksgiving! 🦃 🥧🍁

Photos from Little Italy Pizza's post 11/16/2021

We would like to thank everyone who attended Little Italys 49th anniversary. We appreciate everyones support for 49 years and counting!

We would also like to give a big thanks to our staff members and volunteers for working hard on our big day.

We hope to see you all for next years big 50th where we will be having a huge surprise for everyone!

-Little Italy Family

11/14/2021

Gangs all here!

Photos from Little Italy Pizza's post 11/13/2021

Can’t wait to see everyone tomorrow!
Festivities start at 11am see you then. 🍕 🍻 🎉

11/11/2021

T-shirts Hot Off The Press. 🥵 🔥
Anniversary in 3 days see you all soon!

Thanks to LogoHQ for helping us create one of our favorite T Shirt designs. We are very excited for you guys to grab one.

10/03/2021

We missed you all last year and we are so excited we get to do it this year! Come celebrate 49 years of Little Italy Pizza.

Raffles, Contest prizes, music, and did I mention 49cent Pizza Slices?!

We will be giving away Little Italy T-shirts that are only available at this event. You don’t want to miss this! We can’t wait to celebrate this special day with everyone!

09/29/2021

We love our customers and reviews like this put a big smile on our face! 🍕😃

Nutritionist says pizza is better for breakfast than most cereals 02/28/2021

It’s good for any meal of the day!

https://www.wbaltv.com/article/nutritionist-says-pizza-is-better-for-breakfast-than-most-cereals/27613136

Nutritionist says pizza is better for breakfast than most cereals What's better to eat for breakfast: pizza or cereal? Turns out, it's actually pizza.

04/09/2020

We are now offering delivery with Doordash.

03/20/2020

Just a heads up for everyone, we are still open. The governor has issued a no dine in policy, so will will be doing only takeout or delivery with post mates. We will let you know if anything changes.

02/15/2020

Hope everyone had a wonderful Valentines Day!

11/10/2019

You’ve left us speechless once again!!! Thank you guys so much, best customers around!!! Party gies on till 8!

11/04/2019

Come get them this Sunday!!!

07/03/2019

We will be open on the 4th! Hope everyone has a wonderful 4th, and a great weekend!

Want your restaurant to be the top-listed Restaurant in Saint Petersburg?
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.

Videos (show all)

Had a surprise visitor yesterday, and Fox 13 had to come by and get the scoop. Special thanks to our crew at Little Ital...
Construction started on Disston Plaza’s new Publix this week, but first the old store has to come down!
Anniversary
Anniversary
Just practicing some of our moves.  #handtossed #oldschool #pizza
First contest of the day, pizza eating contest.

Category

Telephone

Address


3523 49th Street N
Saint Petersburg, FL
33710

Opening Hours

Monday 11am - 10pm
Tuesday 11am - 10pm
Wednesday 11am - 10pm
Thursday 11am - 10pm
Friday 11am - 11pm
Saturday 11am - 11pm
Sunday 11am - 10pm

Other Pizza Places in Saint Petersburg (show all)
Gianni's NY Pizza Gianni's NY Pizza
936 58th Street N
Saint Petersburg, 33710

Truly Authentic New York pizza. Family owned & operated since 1976 producing ultra high quality pizz

Joey Brooklyn's Famous Pizza Kitchen Joey Brooklyn's Famous Pizza Kitchen
210 1st Avenue N
Saint Petersburg, 33701

Spa Beach Bistro Spa Beach Bistro
501 2nd Avenue NE
Saint Petersburg, 33701

Come down to the Spa Beach Bistro located at the new St. Pete Pier and enjoy our casual outdoor dining experience with family-friendly atmosphere and beautiful city skyline views!

The Violet Stone The Violet Stone
2134 9th Avenue N
Saint Petersburg, 33713

Well done pizza 🍕 & sandwiches

Marco's Pizza Marco's Pizza
1360 34th Street N
Saint Petersburg, 33712

Authentic Italian pizza with fresh dough and our original Giammarco recipe sauce. Order online.

The Ohio Pizza Parlor The Ohio Pizza Parlor
7224 Central Avenue
Saint Petersburg, 33707

Serving up thin crust pizza w/ edge to edge toppings, cut into squares! Plus, salads, dessert & beer!

Local Pizza Co. Local Pizza Co.
1846 62 Avenue N
Saint Petersburg, 33702

We're a locally owned & operated business on a mission to partner up with local farmers, brewers and

Colony Grill - St. Petersburg Colony Grill - St. Petersburg
670 Central Avenue
Saint Petersburg, 33701

A pizza unlike any other, Colony Grill is famous for our ‘hot oil bar pie’ & exceptional hospitality.

Marco's Pizza Marco's Pizza
1126 62 Avenue N
Saint Petersburg, 33702

Authentic Italian pizza with fresh dough and our original Giammarco recipe sauce. Order online.

Nicko's Pizza and Subs Nicko's Pizza and Subs
1239 4th Street S
Saint Petersburg, 33701

pizza and sub restaurant

Hungry Howie's Hungry Howie's
4690 49th Street North
Saint Petersburg, 33709

Try our original free flavored crust, and pizza made from the best quality ingredients!

Pizza Hut Pizza Hut
4598 34th Street S
Saint Petersburg, 33711