Hefty Lefty's Hoagies and Grinders

We are so proud to have an Eagle Scout in our Hefty Lefty family. Stella became the first female Eagle Scout in her troop and we celebrated this amazing accomplishment today. Hoagie makers make great Eagle Scouts! Way to go, Stella! ❤️

We are honored to win the Outstanding Market District Business!

Downtown Inc is pleased to announce the winners of the 2024 Downtown First Awards, sponsored by The Glatfelter Agency! The winners from each category represent exceptional businesses, organizations, and individuals who have put Downtown York first, through their commitments of time, advocacy, and resources.

🌟 Outstanding Large Business Presented by Susquehanna Real Estate: Investment Real Estate, LLC
🌟 Outstanding WeCo York, PA District Business/Organization Presented by Stock and Leader, Attorneys at Law: Gather 256
🌟 Outstanding Market District York Business/Organization Presented by CGA Law Firm: Hefty Lefty's Hoagies and Grinders
🌟 Outstanding Royal Square District Business/Organization Presented by Statewide Partners: Picalonga Sabor Tropical
🌟 Outstanding Nonprofit Organization Presented by Shipley Energy: YWCA York
🌟 Better York Appell Beautification Award Presented by Better York: The Rotary Club of York and City of York
🌟 Outstanding Individual Presented by Buchart Horn, Inc.: Tiff Lowe
🌟 The Changemaker Award Presented by Stewart & Tate: Joan Mummert

We are excited to announce we are opening a second location in the Franklin Street Social!!! This Food Hall is a first for York County and will be a destination point for all of Central Pennsylvania. We are ecstatic about the opportunity to serve our customers in such a unique venue!!! Thank you to all of our amazing customers who made this possible!!!

Celebrate with us as we welcome HEFTY LEFTYS to the Franklin Street Social!

Fresh off our their recent awards of “Best of York/Hanover” For Best Sub/Sandwich Shop AND Best Cheesesteak. Hefty Lefty’s brings a great energy to the Red Lion Community.

Know for their signature “Tuck and Roll” presentation, unrivaled quality, attention to detail and great customer service, Hefty Lefty's Hoagies and Grinders is sure to become a landmark at the Franklin Street Social.

We are honored to be voted Best of York and Hanover 2024 (Best of York) for both sub/sandwich shop AND cheesesteaks!!! Thank you to everyone who took the time to vote! We appreciate your support!

We are blessed with an amazing team that helps keep us running full speed and makes this possible! We couldn’t do it without
them.

We will be open Tuesday, July 2 and will then be closed July 3-8. We will re-open Tuesday, July 9. Have a happy Fourth of July!!❤️🇺🇸🎂

Hailstorm Hiking Adventures is led by our very own Mrs. Lefty! Great way to step into backpacking. Check it out!

Thank you for featuring Hefty’s! ❤️

Hoagie Heaven: Hefty Lefty’s draws sub lovers to York’s Central Market - TheBurg Pennsylvanians pride themselves on knowing what constitutes a good hoagie, as opposed to what can be described as “sub” par. For instance, recently, I was speaking to a young teen who learned the cruel ways of the world when she ordered a hoagie while traveling with her family out west. “They ...

A big THANKS to from Charlotte, North Carolina for including Hefty Lefty’s in their trip to Lancaster for the weekend!!! We hope we didn’t slow you down too much🤣

We are looking for a few good Lefty’s! We are in need of morning prep people 6 am - 10 am, grill cook 9 am - 3 pm, hoagie makers 10 am - 3 pm. We offer competitive pay, free lunch, free parking at the Market garage and flexible scheduling. We are open Tuesday through Saturday. For more information DM through Facebook or stop in for an application.

We ❤️ Russy's Sweet Treats!!!!

Hefty Lefty's Hoagies and Grinders
One of many Great Business here at Central Market York stop by and see for yourself!!

The Easter Feaster returns to Hefty Lefty’s! Shaved smoked applewood carver ham with our house made pineapple glaze topped off with Grande Mozzarella and toasted to perfection! Available til Easter! Don’t you dare miss it!!!

We are now accepting online pickup orders for Hoagies and Platters this Sunday. Pickup between 10-2. Please visit heftyleftys.com to order. All platters and hoagie orders must be placed by 3 pm Friday.

Viral hoagie shop calls York Central Market home Hefty Lefty's Hoagies and Grinders recently blew up on social media when a customer posted a photo of their sandwich on a hoagie enthusiast Facebook group.

What a year! We are so grateful for the excitement around hoagies! We never expected this but are grateful to be able to share our love of hoagies with so many people!

Thank you to our customers. We are so happy to continue meeting new faces. We know our lines have been long lately and we appreciate the time spent waiting for a hoagie or cheesesteak. We are new to this type of volume and are doing the best we can.

Thank you to our team! We have a great crew that works so hard! We couldn’t do this without you! Who knew making hoagies could be so much fun! 😜

Cheers to 2024!

Our hours this week:
🔸 Sunday- Closed
🔸 Monday- Closed
🔸 Tuesday- Closed
🔸 Wednesday- 10-2
🔸 Thursday- 10-2
🔸 Friday- 10-2
🔸 Saturday- 10-2

Happy Thanksgiving from the Hefty Lefty family! 🏃‍♂️🦃

Our hours this week:
🔸 Tuesday: 10-2
🔸 Wednesday: 10-2
🔸 Thanksgiving: Closed
🔸 Black Friday: Closed
🔸 Small Biz Saturday: 10-2

We look forward to seeing you this week!

We want to thank everyone for spreading the word about our hoagies and cheesesteaks. We are blessed with amazing customers who share their Hefty Lefty love with others!

Unfortunately, with an increase of in-house customers we are unable to keep up with our online demand. Until we can hire additional hoagie makers to help meet the demand, there may be days that online ordering is unavailable. We do apologize for this inconvenience!

Thank you for your support! We LOVE seeing so many new faces!

Hefty Lefty’s is hiring! Looking for hoagie makers and part time supervisors. Competitive wages, free hoagies, flexible scheduling, free parking downtown and family run business. Message us directly or swing by the market for an app!

The Thanksgiving Grinder has returned!!! Roasted Turkey, to die for stuffing, buttery rich mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce and gravy toasted to perfection! Don’t you dare miss it!!! Available for a limited time!

What a great night! Hefty’s had the privilege of being one of the food vendors for Pink Power York’s Pink in the Park. Grateful to participate in this event for an amazing cause!

Introducing “The Goodfella” from Hefty Lefty’s! Prosciutto, Sopressata, Hot Capocollo, Fresh Mozzarella, olive oil and roasted red peppers. A limited time engagement. Don’t you dare miss it!

We are so excited to be part of this event supporting a great cause! Get your tickets now!

Shout to one of our newest Trail-Friendly Businesses: Hefty Lefty's Hoagies and Grinders at Central Market in Downtown York, PA. While the name is certainly revealing, they also have made to order cheesesteaks and curly fries on the menu. They're open Tuesday to Saturday 10am-2pm and located just two blocks down from the York County Heritage Rail Trail.

Hefty Lefty's is a great place to grab a sandwich to take with you on your trail excursion or to refuel after a day on trail! Either way be sure to stop in and check it out.

Every great hoagie starts with the roll. Our bread come fresh from Jersey every day!!! Nothing like it!!!

Get YOUR hands on a Hailstorm Grinder this week! Turkey, Avocado, Bacon, Housemade Chipotle Mayo and mozzarella cheese toasted to perfection! A limited time release! Don’t you dare miss it!

We will be closed July 4&5. We will re-open on Thursday July6.

In honor of Mrs. Lefty gearing up to hike The Long Trail, we are bringing back the sandwich she created: The Hailstorm Grinder. This fan favorite has Turkey, Bacon, Avocado chunks, housemade chipotle mayonnaise and mozzarella cheese toasted to perfection! Available for a limited time. Don’t you dare miss it!!!