Extraordinary Cupcakes
"Helping others escape the ordinary - one cupcake at a time!" Most days, we have Cake Truffles out to sample, so you might be in for a treat...
This page will hopefully give you an idea of what it's like to step into our shop - that is, a brief escape from your day into our fantasy world of cupcakes! Sing along with classic show tunes, say "Hello" to Emerson the (Ferris-wheel) Peacock or enjoy some great coffee or any of our other hand selected beverages.
05/19/2024
Congratulations Anthony & Abena!
05/19/2024
02/10/2024
Place your order today!
02/09/2024
Come and get your Love
an Extraordinary Valentine's Day Cake!
08/20/2023
Swing into Illy Caffe and grab a brand new Strawberry Shortcake Push Up!
A delicious way to beat the summer heat!!!
08/11/2023
Another Extraordinary birthday!
We know some of you are having trouble locating us since we moved from our location of 11 + years.
We no longer have a storefront but you can still get our extraordinary cupcakes Tuesday - Saturday.
Order for today online then pick up at our kiosk inside Illy Caffe or have them delivered. You can also schedule your order in advance for the day you will need them and tell us what time you would like to pick them up or have them delivered.
We also now have a 3 day advance order option for cakes!
Want to customize an order? Email us at [email protected].
Need to speak with us? Email us your contact info or call us 757-645-2122.
We look forward to making your day extraordinary!
Dyana McGlothlin Steely
Owner
Extraordinary Cupcakes "Helping others escape the ordinary - one cupcake at a time!"
04/13/2023
Delivery is now available!
Thank you all for your patience. Our online ordering system is now in place and delivery is available.
Why the wait time? We bake your order as soon as you place it. As we get a feel for what the numbers will be for the day, we will go back to baking in small batches throughout the day and the preparation time of your order will go back to being what you are used to in our previous location.
We are doing our best to continue to provide you with the cupcakes and cakes you love. Thank you for your continued support and loyalty.
Please visit our website for more information - www.extraordinarycupcakes.com
Dyana McGlothlin Steely
Owner, Extraordinary Cupcakes
Celebrating 11 years.
Helping you escape the ordinary, one cupcake at a time.
04/11/2023
Online ordering is now available! Click here www.extraordinarycupcakes.com for the link on our home page
or scan the QR code below to order, then pick up at our new, brightly lit kiosk inside Illy Caffe.
It's official! We are currently enjoying our new location at 435 W Duke of Gloucester Street, inside Illy Caffe Williamsburg.
In addition to a new location, our ordering process is also new. We have gone digital! To order your beloved cupcakes, simply email us at [email protected] then pick it up in our staging area inside Illy caffe.
Our new online ordering will be in place soon. When it is, you will be able to see what is currently available, set a time and day for pick up, pay, and even have them delivered.
03/30/2023
30 Qt Hobart mixer. Newly serviced. Purchased from Gusty's in Richmond. $3,000 cash.
03/30/2023
2 of these still available. Heavy duty, not like you see online for half the price. $300 each.
03/30/2023
1 of these is still available at the shop and cann be picked up on Friday at 5pm. Price is $150.
Our phone lines are transitioning today instead of Monday, as scheduled.
Please email us at [email protected] with orders and questions.
Thanks so much!
XO
Moving Sale!
We have the following for sale:
30 Qt Hobart Mixer newly serviced $3,000
4 stainless steel work tables 35h x 30d x 72w $300 each
Metal locker unit 78h x 44w x 18d $250
5 Heavy duty metal shelves with pressed wood shelves (used to hold dry ingredients) 72h x 48w x 25d $200 each
Many other items (upright freezer, 3 short rolling racks, 2 tall rolling racks, lexan containers with lids, full sheet and half sheet baking pans, etc... ).
Message us if looking for something specific. Cash only.
Resolution achieved!
We will be open for business tomorrow, regular hours!
We move to our new location at 435 W Duke of Gloucester Street on April 1. We will only be able to do pre-orders that day as we settle into our new home at Illy Caffe Williamsburg.
Extraordinary Cupcakes will be closed while we resolve an issue with our landlord. We apologize for any inconvenience and we hope to be open again soon. If you need to reach out, please email us at [email protected]
02/05/2023
02/05/2023
Yes, we do cakes. Take a look at these Extraordinary cakes for customers yesterday.
02/04/2023
Nothing says "I love you" more than a box of Extraordinary cupcakes. Order yours for the ones you love today.
01/28/2023
Did you ask if we do cakes?!
You bet we do! Order one for the next event you want to be extraordinary.
01/25/2023
Hard to believe it has been 11 years since this was taken. Feels like we have always been a Williamsburg tradition and we have met so many wonderful people over the years. Our customers are the best! Thank you so much for making another year extraordinary!
XO.
01/24/2023
Happy Birthday To Us! Tomorrow, Extraordinary Cupcakes, and our extraordinary front man, Emerson Peacock turn 11! Come in and get your favorite cupcake and wish Emerson a happy birthday. Singing optional.
12/31/2022
We are open today regular hours. Come in for an extraordinary start to a new year!
Click here to claim your Sponsored Listing.
Videos (show all)
Contact the restaurant
Telephone
Address
435 W Duke Of Gloucester Street
Williamsburg, VA
23185
Opening Hours
| Tuesday | 11am - 5pm |
| Wednesday | 11am - 5pm |
| Thursday | 11am - 5pm |
| Friday | 11am - 5pm |
| Saturday | 11am - 5pm |
LOKAL Bread
Williamsburg, 23188
LOKAL Bread bakes organic breads and baked goods with sprouted, whole-grain flour.
The Coffeehouse
5251-6 John Tyler Highway
Williamsburg, 23185
You can now order our coffees beans by calling the store and we will ship them straight to your house! Our website is temporary not working at this time.
Opus 9 Steakhouse
5143 Main Street
Williamsburg, 23188
Delectable entrees are highlighted by our melt-in-your-mouth aged Prime Steak, such as Steak “Osca
Blue Talon Bistro
420 Prince George Street
Williamsburg, 23185
Casual comfort and quality that makes you feel completely at ease.
Green Leafe Cafe & Pub
765 Scotland Street
Williamsburg, 23185
Williamsburg's classic Pub with a beautiful new design. We feature 40 Unique Drafts, extensive liquor selection, and a wonderful Whisky Bar Great Beer, Great Food, Great People, Ba...
The Corner Pocket
4805 Courthouse Street
Williamsburg, 23188
Upscale pool hall & restaurant with great food & craft drinks. Order Online 👉 thecornerpocket.us
Sno-to-Go
2229 Richmond Road
Williamsburg, 23185
Williamsburg's Best Sno Balls. Family-owned, locally-run.
The Whaling Company
494 McLaws Cir
Williamsburg, 23185
We are best known for fresh fish, simply prepared, at resonable prices in a unique, comfortable, entertaining environment.
Old Chickahominy House
1211 Jamestown Road
Williamsburg, 23185
Voted Williamsburg's Best Kept Secret 2007 Voted best breakfast 2013, 2014 and 2015 Voted best gift
Aromas Specialty Coffees & Gourmet Bakery
431 Prince George Street
Williamsburg, 23185
Welcome to our casual home away from home, but with JAVA! Come to eat, drink & be merry! Check out our two locations in Colonial Williamsburg & Newport News across from CNU (www.ca...